(440) 307-2060
Metal vs. Shingle Roof: A Full Comparison
Choosing between a metal roof vs asphalt shingles is one of the most important decisions a homeowner or builder can make. Each option has advantages and drawbacks, and the best choice depends on climate, budget, building structure, and personal preferences. This guide compares the two options in depth, with a particular focus on real-world concerns—like snow avalanches off metal roofs, seal degradation, Wi-Fi interference, and emergency access issues.
What Are Asphalt Shingles?
Asphalt shingles are made of fiberglass or organic felt saturated with asphalt and coated in ceramic granules. They are one of the most widely used roofing materials in North America due to their low cost and ease of installation.
Pros of Shingle Roofs
- Affordable upfront cost
- Easy to install and repair
- Many styles and colors
- Decent fire resistance
- Readily available materials
Cons of Shingle Roofs
- Shorter lifespan (15–30 years)
- Less resistant to extreme weather
- Prone to curling, cracking, and granule loss
- Higher maintenance over time
- Non-recyclable waste
What Is a Metal Roof?
Metal roofing includes panels or shingles made from steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc. Styles range from standing seam panels to stamped profiles designed to mimic tile or shakes.
Pros of Metal Roofing
- Long lifespan (40–70+ years)
- Low maintenance
- Highly fire-resistant
- Recyclable and eco-friendly
- Reflective coatings reduce heat gain
- Excellent wind and storm resistance
Cons of Metal Roofing
While metal has many strengths, there are critical disadvantages homeowners need to consider.
Metal Roof Drawbacks: What to Watch Out For
1. Snow Slides Can Be Dangerous
On steep two-story homes, metal roofs allow snow to shed rapidly. That may sound like a benefit—until a massive sheet of snow suddenly slides off and crushes a car or damages landscaping. This avalanche effect is common in snowy regions without snow guards installed. It’s not just an inconvenience—it’s a real safety risk.
Solution: Install snow retention systems and avoid parking directly under eaves during winter.
2. Screw Seals Can Dry-Rot and Fail
Most metal roofs are installed using exposed fasteners with rubber or neoprene washers. Over time, UV exposure, heat cycles, and cold weather cause these seals to degrade. When the rubber cracks or shrinks, water can seep in around the screws, leading to leaks and rot beneath the panels.
Solution: Schedule regular inspections every few years and plan to replace or re-seal screws over the life of the roof.
3. Firefighter Entry Is More Difficult
In emergencies, firefighters often need to cut ventilation holes into the roof to release heat and smoke. While shingles and wood decking can be breached quickly, a metal roof slows them down. Metal is harder to cut through, especially with layered underlayment or insulation, delaying rescue and suppression.
Implication: Homes with metal roofs may need more time for emergency crews to ventilate or access the attic during a fire.
4. Wi-Fi and Cell Signal May Be Reduced
Metal acts as a barrier to radio frequency signals. In homes with weak reception to begin with, installing a metal roof can further degrade Wi-Fi and cellular signal. Some homeowners report having to switch to mesh networks, boosters, or Wi-Fi calling to stay connected.
Important: If your area already struggles with reception, expect some additional issues after switching to a metal roof—especially on single-story homes surrounded by trees or hills.
5. Metal Shows Imperfections Easily
If your roof structure isn’t perfectly straight or flat, metal panels will make it obvious. Sagging trusses, uneven decking, or dips between rafters may telegraph through the rigid metal finish.
Tip: Always inspect and correct structural flaws before installing metal. Any flaws in the decking will be much more visible than with flexible shingles.
6. Dents from Hail or Tree Branches
Metal is tough, but not invincible. Softer metals like aluminum or copper dent easily from hail, tree branches, or falling debris. While steel is more resistant, it’s still possible to end up with visible indentations that are difficult to repair without replacing entire panels.
Shingles, on the other hand, can sometimes self-heal from small hail impacts or be replaced in small sections without requiring a whole roof panel swap.
Metal vs. Shingle: Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Metal Roofing | Asphalt Shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | Higher ($8–16/sq ft) | Lower ($3–7/sq ft) |
| Lifespan | 40–70+ years | 15–30 years |
| Durability | Excellent | Moderate |
| Snow Shedding | Sudden and heavy | Gradual |
| Fire Resistance | Excellent | Good |
| Signal Interference | Possible | None |
| Ease of Repair | More complex | Easier, localized fixes |
| Aesthetic Options | Fewer, more modern | Wide variety |
| Recyclability | High | Low |
| Noise | Louder (unless insulated) | Quiet |
Aesthetics and Appearance
Metal roofs tend to have a modern or industrial look, which can be a pro or con depending on the home’s architecture. Shingles, especially architectural ones, offer more traditional curb appeal and are easier to blend into older neighborhoods.
Metal also shows aging, dents, or scratches more clearly, while shingles wear in a more gradual, less noticeable way.
Energy Efficiency
Both roofs can be energy-efficient in different ways:
- Metal roofing reflects solar heat when coated with a reflective finish, lowering cooling costs.
- Shingles absorb heat but insulate more effectively in colder climates.
Your region’s climate will heavily influence which roof type is more efficient for your situation.
Maintenance Needs
Shingle Roof Maintenance
- Replace missing or damaged shingles
- Inspect flashing and valleys annually
- Clean off moss, algae, or leaf buildup
- Resurface or seal every 10–15 years in some cases
Metal Roof Maintenance
- Inspect for loose fasteners and dry-rotted rubber seals
- Re-seal or replace fasteners every 10–20 years
- Remove debris and overhanging branches to prevent dents
- Clean and check for corrosion or fading coatings
Long-Term Value
While metal roofs are more expensive up front, they often prove more cost-effective over time:
- Fewer replacements
- Lower maintenance
- Higher resale value
- Possible insurance discounts (due to fire and wind resistance)
Shingles require more frequent replacement and can suffer storm damage more easily, but their lower price point makes them appealing for short-term budgeting.
What Type of Home Should Choose Metal?
Metal is a great choice for:
- Homes in wildfire or storm-prone areas
- Long-term homeowners planning to stay 20+ years
- Buildings with steep slopes that benefit from snow-shedding
- Modern or minimalist architecture
However, owners should budget for added features like:
- Snow guards in cold climates
- Additional insulation to reduce noise
- Signal boosters if needed
What Type of Home Should Choose Shingles?
Shingles work well for:
- First-time buyers or homes being flipped
- Homeowners on a tighter budget
- Traditional homes and HOAs requiring specific aesthetics
- Properties in areas with lower hail and wildfire risk
Repairs are quick and localized, and the material is readily available from nearly every roofing supplier.
Conclusion: Which Roof Wins?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but here’s a general breakdown:
- Choose metal if you value durability, longevity, energy savings, and can afford the upfront cost. But prepare for snow control, potential signal interference, and higher repair complexity.
- Choose shingles if you prefer simplicity, affordability, and a classic appearance, and are okay with replacing the roof in 20 years.
Every home is different. Assess your budget, climate, roof pitch, and long-term plans before making the call.
