8 Red Flags to Look Out for on Your Roof Estimate

When reviewing a roof estimate, it’s important to look beyond just the price. A well-documented estimate should provide a clear and detailed breakdown of the scope of work, materials, warranties, and contractor responsibilities. If something seems vague or missing, you may be dealing with a roofing contractor that isn’t transparent or trustworthy. Below are eight red flags to watch out for when reviewing your roof estimate.

1. The Scope of Work Is Vague

A trustworthy roofing estimate should clearly outline the work to be completed, including:

• The type of roofing material being installed
• Layers of old roofing being removed (if applicable)
• Installation of underlayment, flashing, and ventilation
• Any repairs to roof decking or structure
• Cleanup and disposal of old materials

If the estimate lacks specifics and only gives a broad statement like “roof replacement,” you won’t know what you’re paying for, and it could lead to unexpected costs later.

2. The Roof Estimate Only Comes With a Price

A professional roofing estimate should be detailed and itemized, listing:

• Cost of materials
• Labor costs
• Additional fees (such as permits or disposal fees)
• Warranty details

If a contractor only provides a lump-sum price without a breakdown, they might be hiding costs or cutting corners on materials and labor quality.

3. Hiding the Roof Estimate’s Fine Print

Always read the fine print on your roofing estimate. Some contractors include vague clauses or exclusions that could lead to unexpected charges. Look out for terms related to:

• Extra fees for “unforeseen” work
• Cancellation policies
• Limited liability for damage during installation

A reliable contractor will clearly explain all terms upfront and ensure you understand them before signing.

4. Hidden Fees That Bring the Initial Roof Estimate Price Down

Some contractors will provide an attractively low initial estimate but include hidden fees that inflate the final cost. Watch out for:

• Charges for materials that should be included in the base price
• Additional costs for work that should be standard (like removing old shingles)
• Extra fees for site cleanup and waste disposal

A legitimate roofing estimate should be transparent and include everything needed to complete the job as quoted.

5. There’s Nothing About Protecting Your Property in the Estimate

Roofing work can cause damage to landscaping, driveways, and exterior features if proper precautions aren’t taken. A reputable roofing contractor will outline how they plan to protect your property, such as:

• Using plywood to shield windows and doors
• Covering plants and landscaping
• Ensuring proper disposal of debris

If there’s no mention of property protection, it could indicate a careless approach to your home’s safety.

6. Clauses That State a Roofer Isn’t Liable for Property Damage

Some estimates contain clauses that release the contractor from responsibility for any accidental property damage. This is a major red flag because it means:

• If your landscaping, gutters, or siding get damaged, you’ll have to pay for repairs
• The roofing crew may not take necessary precautions to minimize damage

A professional roofing company should take full accountability for their work and any damage they may cause.

7. No Mention of Warranties on Materials or Workmanship

Roofing warranties typically fall into two categories:

• Manufacturer warranties, which cover defects in roofing materials
• Workmanship warranties, which cover errors in installation

If the estimate doesn’t mention warranties, it could mean:

• The contractor is using subpar materials
• They don’t stand by their work

A trustworthy contractor will clearly outline both types of warranties and what they cover.

8. No Proof of Licensing, Insurance, or Certifications

Before signing any roofing contract, verify that the contractor provides proof of:

• State licensing (if required in your area)
• General liability insurance (to cover accidental damage to your property)
• Workers’ compensation insurance (to protect workers and prevent liability on your part)
• Manufacturer certifications (such as Owens Corning Preferred Contractor status)

If an estimate lacks this information, it could mean the contractor isn’t properly licensed or insured, putting you at financial risk.

---

Final Thoughts

A well-documented roofing estimate ensures transparency, protects you from hidden costs, and gives you confidence in the contractor’s professionalism. If you notice any of these red flags, consider getting additional estimates from reputable contractors.

For a detailed, transparent, and professional roof estimate, contact S&K Construction and Remodeling LLC. As an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, we ensure every estimate includes a clear scope of work, fair pricing, and warranty details to protect your investment.