(440) 307-2060
8 Signs of a Bad Roofing Contractor: What You Need to Know Before Hiring
Choosing the right roofing contractor is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when it comes to installing or repairing your roof. After all, your roof is one of the most critical elements of your home, protecting your family and belongings from the elements. Unfortunately, not all roofing contractors are created equal. Some may not have the experience, expertise, or professionalism required to deliver high-quality work. Worse, some may try to cut corners or even engage in fraudulent practices.
To ensure you hire a trustworthy and reliable contractor, it’s essential to know the signs of a bad roofing contractor. In this blog post, we’ll discuss eight warning signs that suggest you might be dealing with a bad roofing contractor. By understanding these red flags, you can make an informed decision and avoid costly mistakes.
1. The Roofing Contractor Isn’t Licensed, Bonded, and Insured
When hiring a roofing contractor, one of the first things you should check is whether they are licensed, bonded, and insured. These three qualifications are crucial for protecting yourself as a homeowner, your property, and your financial investment.
A. Licensed
A licensed roofing contractor has met the necessary requirements set by your local or state government, proving that they are qualified to perform roofing work. This may include passing exams, demonstrating knowledge of local building codes, and completing continuing education. If the contractor isn’t licensed, it’s a major red flag. Working with an unlicensed roofer could lead to subpar work or even violations of building codes.
B. Bonded
A bonded contractor has secured a bond that protects you in the event that the work is incomplete, substandard, or does not meet the agreed-upon terms. Bonding ensures that you have a financial recourse if something goes wrong with the roofing job.
C. Insured
Insurance is essential in protecting both you and the contractor in case of accidents or property damage. A reputable roofing contractor should have general liability insurance and workers’ compensation insurance. If a worker is injured while working on your roof and the contractor doesn’t have insurance, you could be held liable for medical expenses.
Hiring a contractor who isn’t properly licensed, bonded, and insured leaves you exposed to a variety of risks, including financial loss, property damage, and legal issues. Always ask for proof of these credentials before signing a contract.
2. The Roofing Contractor Is from an Out-of-State Company
While it’s not a deal-breaker in every case, a roofing contractor that is based in another state can present several potential issues. Working with a local roofing contractor is always the safer and smarter option. Here’s why:
A. Lack of Local Knowledge
A roofing contractor from out of state may not be familiar with the local climate, building codes, or typical roofing issues that are specific to your area. For example, roofing requirements in Cleveland may be different from those in Medina, and local contractors will understand these differences.
B. Difficulty in Communication
If the roofing contractor is from out of state, communication may become difficult, especially if there are issues that arise during or after the roofing job. It can be challenging to get prompt responses or have someone available for follow-up services.
C. Limited Accountability
Hiring a local roofing company offers greater accountability. Local contractors rely on word-of-mouth referrals, repeat customers, and their reputation in the community. If a roofing contractor is out of state, it may be harder to hold them accountable if something goes wrong or if you need them for warranty work.
A local contractor will be more accessible and more invested in doing quality work. Choosing a local roofer in Beachwood or Chagrin Falls can give you peace of mind that you’re working with someone who understands your specific needs.
3. They Want You to Sign Something Before a Roof Inspection
A trustworthy roofing contractor will always inspect your roof before providing an estimate. If a contractor is asking you to sign a contract or agree to services before they’ve assessed the condition of your roof, this is a significant warning sign.
A. Unnecessary Pressure
Reputable contractors understand that an accurate estimate can only be provided after evaluating your roof’s condition. If someone is asking you to sign a contract or make a decision before they’ve inspected your roof, they may be pressuring you into a decision prematurely, often to lock you into a deal.
B. Lack of Transparency
Signing a contract before an inspection could mean you’re agreeing to terms or costs that haven’t been properly explained. The roofing contractor may use this tactic to secure your business without giving you all the necessary information about the work needed.
A professional roofer will take the time to thoroughly inspect your roof, assess any damage, and explain the work required. They’ll only ask for your signature once you have all the facts.
4. The Reviews for the Roofing Company Aren’t Good
Online reviews are an invaluable tool for evaluating roofing contractors. If a contractor has mostly negative reviews or a lack of reviews altogether, this is a clear indication that they may not be trustworthy.
A. Too Many Negative Reviews
Take the time to read through the reviews and look for common complaints. If multiple customers have mentioned the same issues, such as poor communication, bad workmanship, or missed deadlines, this should raise a red flag.
B. Lack of Reviews
While it’s possible that a newer contractor may have fewer reviews, established companies should have a solid online presence. If you’re struggling to find reviews for a roofing company or if they have no reviews at all, it could indicate that they’re not as experienced or reputable as they claim.
Make sure to research the contractor on platforms like Google, Yelp, and the Better Business Bureau (BBB). If you find lots of positive reviews and references, that’s a good sign that the company is trustworthy.
5. Your Estimate Isn’t Broken Down by Line Items
A reputable roofing contractor will provide you with an itemized estimate that breaks down the costs for materials, labor, permits, and other associated expenses. If a roofing contractor offers a vague or lump-sum estimate without detailing the specific costs, this is a sign that they may not be as transparent or trustworthy as they should be.
A. Lack of Transparency
A breakdown of costs allows you to see exactly what you’re paying for and helps you compare estimates from different contractors. Without this transparency, you won’t know whether you’re being charged fairly or if there are hidden fees that could drive up the cost.
B. Possible Overcharging
If the estimate isn’t broken down, it could also indicate that the contractor is trying to hide excessive charges or overcharging for materials. An honest contractor will have no problem explaining the costs and providing detailed information.
6. The Roofing Contractor Isn’t Willing to Go Over the Final Quote With You
Once you’ve received an estimate, a good roofing contractor will be willing to go over the final quote with you. If a contractor is hesitant to explain the details or answer your questions about the estimate, this could be a sign that something is wrong.
A. Avoiding Clarification
Roofing contractors should be transparent and open to discussing the details of the estimate. If you ask for clarification on certain costs and the contractor becomes defensive or evasive, this could be an indication that they’re hiding something.
B. Unwilling to Negotiate
If a contractor is unwilling to discuss the terms of the quote or seems unwilling to work with you on pricing, this could mean they are not interested in providing customer service or building a long-term relationship.
Make sure you’re comfortable with the final quote before proceeding. If a contractor isn’t willing to explain their prices or answer your questions, it’s a red flag.
7. Their Workmanship Warranty Doesn’t Offer Long-Term Protection
A workmanship warranty is an essential component of any roofing project. It guarantees that the contractor will stand behind the quality of their work and address any issues that arise due to poor workmanship.
A. Short Warranty Period
If a roofing contractor offers a very short warranty or no warranty at all, it could indicate that they’re not confident in the quality of their work or that they don’t plan to be around to handle potential issues in the future.
B. Lack of Warranty Details
A reputable roofing contractor will provide a clear, written warranty that specifies the duration of coverage and the types of problems that are covered. If they’re unwilling to provide such a warranty or the warranty details seem vague, it’s a major red flag.
A solid warranty provides peace of mind that the contractor will stand behind their work and fix any issues that arise after the job is complete. Be cautious if the contractor doesn’t offer a comprehensive warranty.
8. Willingness to Lower Their Prices to Win Your Business
While it’s important to get the best deal possible, if a roofing contractor is overly willing to lower their prices in order to win your business, this could be a sign that they’re cutting corners.
A. Unrealistically Low Quotes
If a roofing contractor offers a price that’s significantly lower than other estimates, it could mean they are using inferior materials or cutting corners on installation. This may lead to subpar workmanship and poor long-term performance of your roof.
B. Cheap Materials
Contractors who are eager to lower their prices may be using low-quality or less durable materials to make the job cheaper. This could result in costly repairs down the road or a roof that doesn’t last as long as you were expecting.
While you want to find a fair price, it’s essential not to fall for a contractor who is desperate to lower their prices. The best roofing companies understand that quality work and quality materials come at a price.
Conclusion
When hiring a roofing contractor, it’s crucial to do your research and make sure you’re working with a reputable company. The eight warning signs outlined above can help you spot a bad roofing contractor and avoid costly mistakes. These signs include:
- Not licensed, bonded, and insured
- Out-of-state contractors
- Asking you to sign something before an inspection
- Poor or no online reviews
- Vague estimates without line items
- Unwillingness to go over the final quote
- Lack of long-term workmanship warranty
- Willingness to lower prices to win your business
If you notice any of these signs when dealing with a roofing contractor, it’s a good idea to move on and find someone more trustworthy. If you’re looking for reliable and professional roofing services, make sure to hire a contractor with a good reputation, proper credentials, and a commitment to high-quality work. S&K Construction and Remodeling LLC offers roofing services in Cleveland, Lakewood, Medina, and other areas, and we’re always happy to provide a free estimate and answer any questions about your roofing needs. Contact us today to get started!
