(440) 307-2060
What Is a Shake Roof? A Complete Homeowner’s Guide
If you’re exploring roofing options, you may have asked: what is a shake roof? Shake roofs are a type of wooden roof covering that offers a distinct, rustic appearance and long-lasting durability. Unlike standard asphalt shingles, shake roofing provides a textured, natural look that adds charm and character to homes. Understanding what a shake roof is, how it’s made, its advantages, disadvantages, and maintenance requirements is essential for homeowners considering this roofing option.
This guide delves into every aspect of shake roofs, from material types and installation methods to costs, lifespan, and common issues. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of whether a shake roof is right for your home.
Understanding Shake Roofs
A shake roof is a wooden roof made from split logs or sawn timber. Shakes are thicker than traditional wood shingles, providing enhanced durability, insulation, and resistance to weather. Historically, shake roofs were hand-split from oak, cedar, or other hardwoods, giving them a unique texture and rustic appeal.
How Shake Roofs Differ from Shingles
While both shakes and shingles are made from wood, the key differences include:
- Thickness: Shakes are thicker and more substantial than wood shingles.
- Texture: Shakes have a rough, split surface, while shingles are sawn smooth.
- Durability: Shake roofs tend to last longer and resist wind damage better than thin shingles.
- Aesthetic: Shakes create a more rustic, natural appearance compared to the uniform look of shingles.
Cedar is the most common material used for shake roofs due to its natural resistance to rot, insects, and decay. Other woods, such as redwood or pine, are also used but may require additional treatment.
Types of Shake Roofs
Shake roofs can be categorized based on how the wood is processed:
1. Hand-Split Shakes
- Made by splitting logs with a froe and mallet
- Rough, textured surface
- Thickest and most durable type of shake
- Offers a highly rustic, traditional appearance
2. Tapered or Resawn Shakes
- Logs are sawn on one or both sides for uniform thickness
- Smoother surface than hand-split shakes
- Provides a more modern, consistent look
- Slightly less durable than hand-split shakes
3. Pressure-Treated Shakes
- Chemically treated to resist fire, insects, and mold
- Often required in areas with fire codes
- Slightly alters natural appearance and color
4. Cedar Shakes vs Other Wood Shakes
- Cedar: Naturally resistant to decay and insects; develops a gray patina over time
- Redwood: Strong and visually appealing but more expensive
- Pine or Other Softwoods: Less durable; may require more maintenance and treatment
Advantages of a Shake Roof
Shake roofs offer several benefits that make them a desirable option for homeowners:
1. Aesthetic Appeal
- Unique, rustic look that enhances curb appeal
- Adds character and natural texture to homes
- Can complement traditional, craftsman, or rustic architectural styles
2. Durability and Longevity
- Hand-split shakes can last 30–40 years or more with proper maintenance
- Thicker wood provides better resistance to wind and impact than standard shingles
3. Natural Insulation
- Wood shakes offer better insulation properties than asphalt shingles
- Helps regulate attic temperature, potentially lowering energy costs
4. Eco-Friendly Option
- Made from natural, renewable materials
- Biodegradable at the end of life
- Can be sourced from sustainably managed forests
5. Fire Resistance (with Treatment)
- Pressure-treated shakes provide enhanced fire protection
- Suitable for areas with fire regulations or wildfire concerns
Disadvantages of a Shake Roof
While shake roofs are beautiful and durable, they also come with certain drawbacks:
1. Higher Cost
- Shake roofs are more expensive than asphalt shingles or metal roofing
- Installation labor is also higher due to specialized craftsmanship
2. Maintenance Requirements
- Requires regular inspections to prevent rot, mold, or insect infestations
- Cleaning moss, debris, or leaves is essential to maintain longevity
3. Fire Risk (Untreated)
- Untreated wood is combustible
- Fire-retardant treatments or building code compliance is necessary in fire-prone areas
4. Susceptibility to Moisture
- Prolonged exposure to water can cause rot or warping
- Proper ventilation and gutter maintenance are critical
5. Installation Complexity
- Requires skilled roofing professionals familiar with shake roofing
- Improper installation can lead to leaks and premature deterioration
Installation Process for Shake Roofs
Proper installation is key to the performance of a shake roof. The process generally includes the following steps:
- Inspect Roof Decking: Ensure that the underlying sheathing is in good condition.
- Install Underlayment: Place a water-resistant underlayment to protect against moisture.
- Lay Starter Shakes: Begin at the eaves, overlapping shakes for proper water shedding.
- Install Shakes in Rows: Stagger joints to enhance durability and aesthetic appeal.
- Fasten Shakes Securely: Use stainless steel or corrosion-resistant nails for longevity.
- Install Ridge Caps and Flashing: Ensure proper sealing at peaks, valleys, and roof penetrations.
Professional installation is highly recommended due to the specialized techniques involved. Improperly installed shakes can lead to leaks, rot, and reduced lifespan.
Cost of a Shake Roof
The cost of a shake roof depends on the wood type, shake style, roof complexity, and labor. Here’s an estimated breakdown for a typical residential roof:
| Shake Type | Material Cost per Square Foot | Installation Cost per Square Foot | Total Estimated Cost for 1,500 Sq Ft Roof | Lifespan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hand-Split Cedar | $6–$10 | $8–$15 | $21,000–$37,500 | 30–40 years |
| Tapered/Resawn Cedar | $4–$8 | $7–$12 | $16,500–$30,000 | 25–35 years |
| Pressure-Treated Cedar | $5–$9 | $8–$13 | $19,500–$33,000 | 30–40 years |
Note: Costs vary based on roof slope, geographic location, and contractor expertise.
While shake roofs are more expensive than asphalt shingles, their longevity, aesthetic appeal, and energy efficiency can offset the initial investment over time.
Maintenance Tips for Shake Roofs
Maintaining a shake roof ensures its longevity and performance:
- Regular Inspections: Check for damaged, cracked, or split shakes at least twice a year.
- Clean Debris: Remove leaves, moss, and branches that retain moisture.
- Check for Mold or Rot: Address any signs of decay promptly with treatment or replacement.
- Maintain Gutters: Proper drainage prevents water pooling that can damage shakes.
- Fire Safety: Consider fire-retardant treatments, especially in wildfire-prone areas.
Routine maintenance can extend a shake roof’s lifespan and protect your investment.
Shake Roofs and Weather Considerations
Shake roofs perform differently depending on climate:
1. Rainy or Humid Climates
- Proper ventilation is essential to prevent rot and mold.
- Pressure-treated shakes resist moisture-related damage.
2. Cold or Snowy Climates
- Shake roofs shed snow well due to their overlapping design.
- Ice dams may form if attic ventilation is inadequate.
3. Hot or Dry Climates
- Untreated shakes may dry out and crack in extreme heat.
- Fire-resistant treatments are recommended in wildfire-prone areas.
Environmental and Energy Benefits
Shake roofs are environmentally friendly and can contribute to energy efficiency:
- Made from renewable wood sources
- Biodegradable and recyclable at end-of-life
- Natural insulation reduces energy consumption for heating and cooling
- Reflects some sunlight, reducing heat absorption compared to darker asphalt shingles
Comparing Shake Roofs to Other Roofing Options
| Roof Type | Lifespan | Aesthetic | Cost | Maintenance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shake Roof | 30–40 years | Rustic, natural, textured | High | Moderate |
| Asphalt Shingle | 15–25 years | Uniform, traditional | Low | Low |
| Metal Roof | 40–70 years | Modern, sleek | High | Low |
| Tile Roof | 50+ years | Mediterranean, upscale | Very High | Low |
| Slate Roof | 75–100 years | Elegant, premium | Very High | Low |
Shake roofs occupy a niche for homeowners seeking natural aesthetics, durability, and moderate maintenance.
FAQs About Shake Roofs
1. How long does a shake roof last?
- 30–40 years for hand-split shakes; 25–35 years for resawn shakes.
2. Are shake roofs fire-resistant?
- Untreated shakes are combustible. Pressure-treated shakes meet fire safety standards.
3. Can I install a shake roof over an existing roof?
- Typically, shakes require removal of old roofing and inspection of sheathing for optimal performance.
4. Do shake roofs require more maintenance than shingles?
- Yes, they require periodic inspections, cleaning, and occasional treatment.
5. Is a shake roof eco-friendly?
- Yes, made from renewable, biodegradable wood, especially when sourced sustainably.
Conclusion
A shake roof offers a unique combination of natural beauty, durability, and environmental benefits. Unlike traditional asphalt shingles, shake roofs provide a rustic, textured look that enhances curb appeal and adds value to your home. Proper installation, regular maintenance, and attention to weather-related considerations are essential for maximizing lifespan and performance.
Although shake roofs come with higher upfront costs and require more upkeep, their aesthetic charm, energy efficiency, and long-term durability make them an attractive choice for homeowners seeking a distinctive roofing solution. Understanding what a shake roof is and how it performs allows homeowners to make informed decisions that protect their investment and enhance the beauty of their home for decades to come. 440-235-3124
