(440) 307-2060
Are Metal Roofs Better?
Choosing the right roof for your home is about more than just looks. It’s an important investment that affects your home’s durability, energy efficiency, safety, and long-term value. With so many materials available—shingles, tile, slate, wood, and more—metal roofing has become an increasingly popular choice. But are metal roofs better?
This guide explores the pros and cons of metal roofing, compares it to traditional materials, and helps you decide if it’s the right fit for your home.
1. How Long Do Metal Roofs Last?
One of the biggest reasons homeowners choose metal roofing is longevity. A well-installed metal roof can last anywhere from 40 to 70 years—or even longer with proper care. In contrast, standard asphalt shingles usually need replacement every 15 to 30 years. If you’re thinking long-term, metal is one of the most durable options available.
Some premium metal roofs (like copper or zinc) can even outlast a century, offering unmatched lifespan compared to other materials.
2. Durability in Harsh Weather
Metal roofs are built to take a beating from the elements. They perform especially well in areas with extreme weather, including:
- High winds – Many metal roofs can withstand gusts up to 140 mph or more.
- Heavy snow – Snow tends to slide off metal, reducing the risk of buildup and collapse.
- Hail and impact – While some softer metals may dent, many metal roofs are impact-rated.
- Fire resistance – Most metal roofs are non-combustible, offering added protection during wildfires or lightning storms.
Overall, if you live in a region with unpredictable or severe weather, metal roofing provides peace of mind.
3. Energy Efficiency and Comfort
Metal roofs reflect solar heat rather than absorb it, which can help keep your home cooler in the summer. This reflective property reduces the demand on your air conditioning system and can lower your cooling costs—especially in hot or sunny climates.
There are also metal roofing systems that include insulation layers, reflective coatings, or “cool roof” technology to further improve energy performance.
However, in colder regions, the same reflective quality may slightly increase heating demands during winter. The key is proper insulation beneath the roof, which balances energy use throughout the year.
4. Environmental Impact
If you’re concerned about sustainability, metal roofing checks several boxes:
- Recyclable – Metal is fully recyclable at the end of its life.
- Made from recycled materials – Many products are manufactured using recycled content.
- Low waste – Unlike shingles that often go to landfills, metal can be reused or reprocessed.
- Energy savings – Reflective roofs contribute to lower carbon emissions through reduced cooling needs.
Metal roofing is a smart choice for eco-conscious homeowners who want to reduce their environmental footprint over time.
5. Maintenance Requirements
One of the hidden benefits of metal roofs is their low maintenance needs. Once installed properly, a metal roof typically requires little more than:
- Occasional inspections (especially after storms)
- Keeping gutters clear of debris
- Ensuring flashing and sealants remain intact
Unlike wood or asphalt, metal won’t rot, mold, crack, or attract insects. That makes it an excellent option for homeowners who prefer to “set it and forget it.”
6. Design and Aesthetic Flexibility
Metal roofing has come a long way from the basic tin sheets used decades ago. Today’s styles include:
- Standing seam panels – Sleek, modern, and clean-lined
- Metal shingles – Designed to mimic wood, slate, or traditional shingles
- Textured finishes – For added depth and curb appeal
- Wide color ranges – From neutral earth tones to bold architectural hues
This variety allows you to match your home’s style—whether modern, rustic, farmhouse, or colonial—with a roofing material that elevates the overall appearance.
Additionally, metal’s light weight makes it easier to install over existing shingles in some situations, which can reduce removal costs and waste. (Always check local codes before doing so.)
7. Noise Levels and Soundproofing
A common concern about metal roofing is noise during rain or hail. While it’s true that bare metal can be loud, most modern installations include insulation, underlayment, or attic barriers that greatly reduce sound transmission.
In fact, with proper materials and installation, a metal roof can be just as quiet as any other roofing type.
If noise is a major concern, be sure to discuss soundproofing layers with your installer. The difference comes down to how the system is built, not just the roofing material itself.
8. Thermal Expansion and Movement
Metal naturally expands and contracts with temperature changes. This means it’s critical for the roof system to include special fasteners, clips, and design considerations that accommodate this movement.
Without proper detailing, the movement could cause screws to loosen or panels to warp over time. Reputable contractors will plan for this during installation to maintain long-term performance.
9. Denting and Durability by Material Type
Not all metal roofs are created equal. The type of metal used can affect dent resistance and overall strength:
- Steel – Strong, durable, and common for residential roofs. Good resistance to hail.
- Aluminum – Lightweight and rust-resistant. Softer, so more prone to denting.
- Copper – Extremely long-lasting and develops a patina over time. Softer and expensive.
- Zinc – Self-healing and corrosion-resistant. Also high-end and more costly.
If you live in a hail-prone area, steel may be a better option than aluminum due to its higher impact resistance.
10. Slippery Surfaces and Safety
Metal roofs are slick, especially when wet or covered in snow. This property helps snow slide off quickly, but it can also make maintenance or cleaning more dangerous.
For homes where access is needed (for solar panels, chimney cleaning, or gutter work), safety equipment and professional help may be necessary.
Some roof designs include snow guards or rails to slow the slide and prevent large sheets of snow from falling off suddenly near walkways or driveways.
11. Color Retention and Fading
Over time, roof colors naturally fade from exposure to sun and weather. Metal roofing finishes are typically treated with fade-resistant coatings, but eventually, some change in appearance is expected.
High-quality painted or coated metal products maintain their color for decades, especially if they’re made with UV-resistant pigments and protective layers.
Choosing a lighter color can also help reduce heat absorption and delay visible fading.
12. Cost: Upfront vs. Long-Term
Here’s where metal roofs face the most scrutiny: price.
- Initial cost – Metal roofing is significantly more expensive upfront than asphalt shingles. Depending on materials and complexity, it can cost 2–3 times more.
- Installation – Requires skilled labor and sometimes special tools or training, which can add to labor costs.
- Long-term value – Because metal lasts so much longer and requires less maintenance, many homeowners see it as a better investment over time.
If you’re planning to stay in your home for decades, the higher upfront cost may pay off by eliminating the need for future replacements and reducing utility bills.
If you’re selling your home soon, the return on investment may depend on market trends and buyer preferences in your area.
13. Insurance and Resale Value
Some insurance providers offer discounts for homes with metal roofs because of their fire and weather resistance. Others may view them neutrally. It’s worth checking with your insurance agent to understand how your choice could affect premiums.
Additionally, a metal roof can boost resale value. Homebuyers may appreciate the durability and energy efficiency benefits, especially if the roof still has most of its lifespan ahead.
14. When a Metal Roof Makes Sense
Here are scenarios where a metal roof could be an ideal choice:
- You’re staying in your home long-term and want to avoid future replacements.
- You live in a severe weather zone and need added protection.
- You’re looking for energy efficiency to reduce long-term costs.
- You care about sustainability and reducing environmental waste.
- You prefer low-maintenance living and long-term peace of mind.
- You want a modern or custom design that stands out architecturally.
15. When to Consider Other Materials
While metal roofing has many strengths, it may not be the right choice for every situation:
- Budget constraints – If upfront cost is the biggest concern, asphalt shingles may be more feasible.
- Short-term living – If you’re selling soon, the long-term value of metal may not be fully realized.
- Noise sensitivity – If soundproofing is inadequate or you’re especially sensitive to noise, other materials might offer better comfort.
Conclusion: So, Are Metal Roofs Better?
The answer depends on what “better” means to you.
If your priorities include long-term durability, energy efficiency, low maintenance, and sustainability, metal roofing outperforms most alternatives. It’s a forward-thinking investment for homeowners who plan to stay put and care about overall home performance.
However, if you’re working within a tight budget or need something quick and simple, traditional materials like asphalt shingles still have their place and can serve well for many years.
Ultimately, it comes down to your goals, budget, climate, and design preferences. Both options have their place—and metal roofing just might be the right one for you.
