(440) 307-2060
Are Metal Roofs Better Than Shingles? A Comprehensive Comparison Guide
When it’s time to replace your roof or build a new home, one of the biggest decisions you face is choosing the right roofing material. For decades, asphalt shingles have been the most popular roofing choice for homeowners across the United States. However, in recent years, metal roofs have surged in popularity due to their durability, energy efficiency, and aesthetic appeal.
So, the big question is: Are metal roofs better than shingles?
At S&K Construction and Remodeling LLC, serving homeowners in Northeast Ohio including Youngstown, Jefferson, and Cleveland, we understand the importance of making an informed choice. This detailed guide will break down everything you need to know — from durability and cost, to maintenance, environmental impact, aesthetics, and more — so you can decide if metal roofing or shingles are the best fit for your home.
What Are Asphalt Shingles?
Before comparing, let’s quickly review what asphalt shingles are.
Asphalt shingles are made primarily of fiberglass or organic felt coated with asphalt and topped with mineral granules. They are the most common roofing material in the U.S. because they’re affordable, easy to install, and come in many styles and colors.
There are two main types:
- 3-Tab Shingles: Basic, flat shingles arranged in a repeating pattern.
- Architectural (Dimensional) Shingles: Thicker and layered for a more textured, premium look.
What Are Metal Roofs?
Metal roofs are made from large panels or shingles crafted from materials such as steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc. These panels are coated with protective finishes to resist rust and corrosion. Metal roofing comes in various styles — standing seam, corrugated panels, metal shingles, and more — that can mimic the look of traditional roofing materials.
Comparing Metal Roofs vs. Shingles: The Key Factors
1. Durability and Lifespan
Metal Roofs:
- Can last 40 to 70 years or more with proper maintenance.
- Resistant to cracking, shrinking, and erosion.
- Withstand harsh weather — heavy rain, hail, strong winds, and snow.
- Metal roofs are non-combustible and highly fire-resistant.
Shingles:
- Typically last 15 to 30 years, depending on quality.
- Susceptible to damage from extreme weather, including hail and wind.
- Can crack, curl, or lose granules over time.
- More vulnerable to algae and moss growth in humid climates.
Winner: Metal roofs offer superior longevity and durability.
2. Cost
Metal Roofs:
- Higher upfront cost: $7 to $14 per square foot installed, depending on the metal type and complexity.
- Installation requires specialized labor, adding to cost.
- Long-term savings due to durability and energy efficiency.
Shingles:
- Lower initial cost: $3 to $6 per square foot installed.
- Widely available and easy to install.
- May require replacement or repairs more frequently.
Winner: Shingles are more affordable upfront, but metal can save money long-term.
3. Energy Efficiency
Metal Roofs:
- Reflect solar radiant heat, reducing cooling costs by 10-25%.
- Many metal roofs come with reflective coatings to improve energy savings.
- Ideal for warmer climates or homes with poor attic ventilation.
Shingles:
- Asphalt shingles absorb heat, which can increase cooling expenses.
- Some “cool roof” shingles exist but typically offer less reflectivity than metal.
Winner: Metal roofs are generally more energy-efficient.
4. Maintenance
Metal Roofs:
- Require minimal maintenance.
- Occasionally inspect for loose panels or fasteners.
- Rarely need cleaning; resist mold, mildew, and insect infestation.
Shingles:
- Require regular inspections for missing, cracked, or curling shingles.
- May need moss or algae treatment in damp climates.
- Repairs more frequent due to weather damage.
Winner: Metal roofs need less ongoing maintenance.
5. Weight
Metal Roofs:
- Lightweight; can often be installed over existing roofs without structural reinforcement.
- Weigh about 50 pounds per square (100 sq. ft.).
Shingles:
- Heavier than metal, usually 240 pounds per square.
- May require roof deck reinforcement when multiple layers are present.
Winner: Metal roofs are lighter and easier on your home’s structure.
6. Installation Time
Metal Roofs:
- Installation can take longer due to specialized techniques and precision.
- Weather can impact installation more severely.
Shingles:
- Faster and easier to install due to standardized processes.
- Widely available contractors can complete projects quicker.
Winner: Shingles install faster, but metal roof installation quality is crucial.
7. Appearance and Style
Metal Roofs:
- Available in a wide range of colors, finishes, and styles.
- Can mimic traditional roofing materials like shingles, slate, or tile.
- Offers a sleek, modern look or classic appeal depending on style.
Shingles:
- Variety of colors and styles, especially architectural shingles.
- Classic and traditional appearance for many home designs.
Winner: Subjective — both offer diverse options; metal offers more modern or custom looks.
8. Environmental Impact
Metal Roofs:
- Often made from recycled materials.
- 100% recyclable at end of life.
- Energy-efficient coatings reduce carbon footprint.
Shingles:
- Mostly petroleum-based, less recyclable.
- End up in landfills more frequently.
- Lower initial environmental impact due to lighter manufacturing.
Winner: Metal roofs are more eco-friendly long-term.
9. Weather Resistance
Metal Roofs:
- Withstand high winds, heavy snow, and hail better than shingles.
- Non-porous and won’t absorb water.
Shingles:
- Can be damaged or lifted by strong winds.
- Prone to granule loss and water absorption over time.
Winner: Metal roofs provide superior weather resistance.
10. Noise
Metal Roofs:
- Can be noisier during rain or hailstorms, especially if not installed with sound-dampening materials.
Shingles:
- Generally quieter due to dense material.
Winner: Shingles offer quieter performance, but soundproofing underlayment can reduce metal roof noise.
Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs
Pros:
- Exceptional lifespan and durability
- Energy efficiency and environmental benefits
- Lightweight and fire-resistant
- Low maintenance requirements
- Wide range of styles and colors
Cons:
- Higher upfront cost
- Installation requires skilled labor
- Can be noisy without proper insulation
- Potential for denting from hail or debris (varies by metal type)
Pros and Cons of Shingles
Pros:
- Lower initial cost
- Wide availability and quick installation
- Traditional aesthetic many homeowners prefer
- Variety of styles and colors, especially architectural shingles
Cons:
- Shorter lifespan (15-30 years)
- Susceptible to weather damage and algae growth
- Requires regular maintenance and inspections
- Heavier weight can stress roof structure if layered
How to Decide: Metal Roof or Shingles?
Here are some key considerations to guide your decision:
Budget
If upfront cost is a primary concern, shingles may be your best bet. However, if you want a long-term investment that reduces future costs, metal roofing is worth considering.
Climate
In regions with heavy snow, hail, or heat, metal roofs often outperform shingles in durability and energy savings.
Home Style
For traditional homes, shingles might better fit the architectural aesthetic. For modern or contemporary designs, metal roofs offer sleek options.
Longevity
If you plan to stay in your home long-term, metal roofs can save money with their extended lifespan.
Environmental Impact
Metal roofing offers a greener choice with recyclability and energy efficiency.
Cost Breakdown: Metal Roof vs. Shingles
| Roofing Type | Average Cost per Square Foot | Lifespan (Years) | Maintenance Cost | Replacement Frequency |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Metal Roof | $7 – $14 | 40-70+ | Low | Rare |
| Asphalt Shingles | $3 – $6 | 15-30 | Moderate | More Frequent |
Financing and Installation with S&K Construction and Remodeling LLC
At S&K Construction and Remodeling LLC, we help homeowners across Northeast Ohio make confident roofing choices. Whether you prefer the traditional appeal of shingles or the modern durability of metal, our team provides:
- Free roofing consultations and estimates
- Expert installation by licensed and insured professionals
- Flexible financing options to fit your budget
- Warranties for materials and workmanship
- Local service in Youngstown, Jefferson, Cleveland, and surrounding areas
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I install a metal roof over shingles?
A: Yes, in many cases metal roofing can be installed over existing shingles, saving on tear-off costs, but a professional inspection is needed.
Q: Are metal roofs noisy during rain?
A: Metal roofs can be louder than shingles, but with proper insulation and underlayment, noise is minimized.
Q: How often do shingles need replacement?
A: Typically every 15-30 years, depending on quality and maintenance.
Q: Do metal roofs attract lightning?
A: No, metal roofs do not increase lightning risk and actually dissipate electrical charges safely.
Q: Which roof is better for resale value?
A: Both improve home value, but metal roofs often offer higher resale value due to longevity and curb appeal.
Conclusion: Are Metal Roofs Better Than Shingles?
The answer
depends on your priorities:
- If you want durability, energy savings, and eco-friendliness — metal roofs are likely the better choice.
- If upfront budget and traditional appearance are most important, shingles remain a solid, popular option.
At S&K Construction and Remodeling LLC, we’re here to help you weigh the pros and cons specific to your home and climate in Northeast Ohio. Contact us for a no-obligation consultation and estimate so you can make the best roofing investment for your home’s future.
Contact S&K Construction and Remodeling LLC
Jefferson, Ohio
