(440) 307-2060
A Roofing Choice More Lake County Homeowners Are Considering
After this past winter’s lake-effect snow and the spring winds that followed, more homeowners across Lake County have been asking us a familiar question:
“Should I stick with asphalt shingles again, or is it time to consider composite (synthetic) shingles?”
It’s an important decision. Most people only replace their roof once or twice in their lives. And when the weather is as unpredictable as it is here, choosing the right material matters more than ever.
When folks come to us at S&K Construction and Remodeling asking about asphalt vs composite shingles, they’re not looking for a pitch — they want real guidance. Something clear, grounded, and based on actual results in our area.
To help you make an informed decision, here’s what we’ll cover:
- What asphalt shingles and composite shingles actually are
- How composite shingles vs asphalt compare in cost, lifespan, and maintenance
- How synthetic vs traditional shingles hold up in Lake County weather
- What to consider before choosing either material
- The real pros and cons of each
- A few examples from local jobs
- Straightforward answers to common homeowner questions
If you’re comparing roofing options and want practical advice, S&K Construction and Remodeling can help.
Understanding Asphalt and Composite Shingles
What Traditional Asphalt Shingles Are
Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material you’ll see throughout Northeastern Ohio. They start with a fiberglass or felt mat, coated in asphalt and topped with granules. They come in different thicknesses and designs, but the core idea is the same: durable, affordable, and widely available.
What Composite (Synthetic) Shingles Are
Composite shingles are engineered from polymers, rubber, or plastic blends. Many are designed to look like traditional shingles — or even premium materials like slate or cedar — but with enhanced longevity and weather resistance.
They’re part of why the conversation around asphalt vs composite shingles has grown. More homeowners want something that lasts longer and holds up better to severe storms.
Why This Decision Matters in Lake County
Weather here changes everything.
Choosing between asphalt and composite shingles isn’t just a matter of comparing price tags. In Lake County, weather plays a major role in how long roofs last.
Between heavy winter snow, freeze-thaw cycles, hail, and hot summers, your roof is under year-round stress. That’s where the synthetic vs traditional shingles conversation becomes real:
- Freeze-thaw cycles can crack or curl older or lower-grade asphalt shingles
- UV exposure can fade asphalt and weaken granules
- Wind and hail can dislodge or fracture shingles
- Ice dams can force water under the surface
Composite shingles are often built specifically to withstand these challenges. That’s why understanding the differences matters more here than in milder climates.
What to Know Before Comparing Costs
Before comparing composite shingles vs asphalt, here are a few considerations that will influence your estimate:
Roof Size and Layout
Larger roofs cost more because they require more material and labor. Roofs with dormers, multiple valleys, steep pitches, or skylights require more time and precision.
Tear-Off vs Overlay
In most Lake County homes, we recommend (and in some cases, require) a full tear-off. It lets us inspect the decking, address ventilation issues, and install new underlayment correctly.
Material Quality
Not all composites — or asphalt shingles — are equal. There are budget, mid-range, and premium versions. Higher-end materials cost more but last longer.
Ventilation and Underlayment
Even the best shingle fails early without proper ventilation or moisture protection. We take these upgrades seriously because they impact lifespan more than many people realize.
Your Long-Term Plans
If you expect to move in the next five years, asphalt may be perfectly fine. If you’re settling into your “forever home,” composite may be worth the investment.
Asphalt vs Composite Shingles: How They Compare
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Asphalt Shingles | Composite (Synthetic) Shingles |
| Lifespan | 20–30 years | 35–50+ years |
| Installed Cost (avg home) | $10,000–$14,000 | $13,000–$18,000+ |
| Weather Resistance | Good | Strong—better against hail, wind, UV |
| Appearance | Clean, simple, traditional | Wider range; can mimic premium materials |
| Maintenance | Occasional repairs | Minimal |
| Warranty | Typically 20–30 years | Often 40–50 years, sometimes transferable |
Real Lake County Example
We recently replaced a 2,600 sq ft roof in Mentor with architectural asphalt shingles. The project cost $12,800, including tear-off, underlayment, ventilation adjustments, and cleanup — completed in one workday.
If the homeowner had chosen composite shingles, we estimate the cost would have been $15,500–$17,000, depending on the specific product. But the lifespan could stretch 40 years or more with fewer repairs.
Both choices are valid — the best one depends on your timeline and priorities.
Deep Dive: Pros and Cons of Each Material
What Matters Most When You’re Making a Decision
Pros of Composite (Synthetic) Shingles
- Longer lifespan
- Better resistance to hail, wind, and UV exposure
- More design options
- Lower long-term maintenance
- Stronger performance in harsh weather
Cons of Composite Shingles
- Higher upfront cost
- Some product lines require special ordering
- Installation can require more precision
- Not every roofer is qualified to install them
Pros of Asphalt Shingles
- Affordable and widely available
- Straightforward to install
- Easy to match for repairs or additions
- Good option for short- or mid-term homeownership
Cons of Asphalt Shingles
- Shorter lifespan
- More susceptible to granule wear, curling, or storm damage
- May require repairs earlier in their life cycle
Every one of these points ties back to the question at the heart of this article: Which roofing material is the better fit for your home?
For some, asphalt is perfectly sufficient. For others, composite is the smarter long-term investment.
Common Roofing Questions from Lake County Homeowners Comparing Asphalt and Composite Shingles
We get these questions regularly from homeowners in Lake County trying to decide between asphalt and composite roofing. If you’re weighing the options, these answers may help you get more clarity before scheduling your estimate.
What is the cost difference between asphalt and composite shingles?
The cost difference between asphalt and composite shingles is usually between $3,000 and $5,000 for a typical Lake County home. Composite shingles cost more upfront due to the materials and longer lifespan, but they often require fewer repairs and replacements over time.
Are composite shingles more durable than asphalt in Ohio weather?
Yes, composite shingles are more durable than asphalt in Ohio’s variable weather. They handle snow, hail, wind, and UV exposure better, making them a good fit for Lake County’s seasonal extremes.
How long do composite shingles last compared to asphalt?
Composite shingles last significantly longer than asphalt shingles. While asphalt shingles generally last 20 to 30 years, composite (synthetic) options often last 35 to 50 years with proper installation.
Will composite shingles improve my home’s resale value?
Composite shingles can improve your home’s resale value by adding curb appeal and reducing the likelihood of near-term repairs. Buyers also value the extended lifespan and warranty coverage.
Do composite shingles require special installation?
Yes, composite shingles often require more precise installation than asphalt shingles. The process may involve specific fasteners or underlayment, so it’s important to work with a contractor experienced in synthetic roofing systems — like S&K Construction and Remodeling.
Is asphalt still a good option for Lake County homes?
Asphalt is still a good option for many homes in Lake County, especially when budget is a key factor. It’s cost-effective, readily available, and offers solid protection when installed correctly, even if it doesn’t last as long as composite materials.
Final Thoughts: Making the Right Roofing Decision
There isn’t a single “best” roofing material — only what’s best for your home and your plans. Asphalt remains a solid, affordable choice. Composite shingles offer longer-lasting protection and may save money over time.
At S&K Construction and Remodeling, we help homeowners across Lake County make thoughtful, informed roof decisions. We look at your home, your goals, and your budget — and offer guidance without pressure.
If you’d like to understand what your roof needs, we’d be happy to take a look.
Schedule your free inspection today, and we’ll walk you through your options with clear numbers and practical advice.
