(440) 307-2060
Best Roofing Underlayment: A Complete Guide for Homeowners
When considering a roof replacement or new installation, many homeowners focus mainly on shingles or tiles. However, one of the most critical elements in a roofing system is often overlooked: the underlayment. Choosing the best roofing underlayment can determine how well your roof stands up to weather, moisture, and time. This hidden but vital layer acts as a barrier between your shingles and roof deck, providing protection against leaks, improving durability, and ensuring your home stays safe.
This guide will explore everything you need to know about roofing underlayment—what it is, the different types available, their benefits, costs, and tips for selecting the right one for your home.
What Is Roofing Underlayment?
Roofing underlayment is a protective layer installed directly on the roof deck, beneath the visible roofing material (shingles, tile, metal, or slate). Its primary function is to provide an extra layer of defense against water infiltration.
If shingles become damaged, blow off, or degrade over time, underlayment prevents moisture from seeping into the wooden roof deck. Without it, leaks can occur more easily, leading to rot, mold, and structural damage.
Why Underlayment Matters
Many homeowners think shingles alone are enough to protect their homes. In reality, shingles are just the outermost defense. Underlayment serves several crucial roles:
- Moisture Barrier – Keeps water from entering when shingles fail.
- Wind Protection – Prevents uplift during storms.
- UV Protection – Some underlayments provide temporary UV resistance during installation.
- Fire Resistance – Certain materials add fire-retardant qualities.
- Temperature Regulation – Helps reflect heat and protect roof decking from thermal stress.
Types of Roofing Underlayment
There are three primary categories of roofing underlayment, each with distinct strengths and weaknesses.
1. Asphalt-Saturated Felt (Felt Paper)
- Description: Traditionally the most common type, often referred to as “tar paper.”
- Advantages:
- Affordable and widely available.
- Provides decent water resistance.
- Drawbacks:
- Tears easily in high winds.
- Less durable in extreme heat.
- Shorter lifespan compared to newer options.
Best Use: Budget projects, moderate climates, short-term installations.
2. Synthetic Underlayment
- Description: Made from polypropylene or polyethylene, synthetic underlayment has become increasingly popular.
- Advantages:
- Lightweight yet strong.
- Highly resistant to tearing.
- Provides excellent water resistance.
- UV resistance allows it to be exposed for weeks during installation.
- Drawbacks:
- Higher upfront cost compared to felt.
- Quality varies by manufacturer.
Best Use: Long-lasting roofs, extreme climates, homeowners looking for durable protection.
3. Rubberized Asphalt Underlayment
- Description: Premium option, often self-adhesive and waterproof.
- Advantages:
- Superior water resistance.
- Self-sealing around nails.
- Great for valleys, eaves, and areas prone to leaks.
- Drawbacks:
- Expensive compared to felt and synthetic.
- Heavier, more difficult to install.
Best Use: High-risk areas like valleys, coastal homes, and regions with heavy rain or snow.
Comparing the Options
| Underlayment Type | Lifespan | Cost Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asphalt Felt | 10–15 yrs | Low | Budget installs, mild climates |
| Synthetic | 20–40 yrs | Moderate | Long-term durability, extreme weather |
| Rubberized Asphalt | 30+ yrs | High | Premium protection, leak-prone areas |
Factors That Influence the Best Roofing Underlayment for You
Selecting the right underlayment depends on several factors:
- Climate – Heavy rainfall, snow, or high winds require stronger materials.
- Roof Material – Metal, slate, and tile roofs often need underlayment with high heat resistance.
- Budget – Asphalt felt is affordable but less durable; synthetic and rubberized offer better long-term value.
- Roof Slope – Low-slope roofs benefit from more waterproof underlayments like rubberized asphalt.
- Installation Timeframe – If your roof won’t be completed right away, UV-resistant synthetic underlayment is ideal.
Signs of Poor or Failing Underlayment
Even with good shingles, your roof can fail if the underlayment wears out. Common signs include:
- Frequent leaks despite intact shingles.
- Rotting roof decking.
- Mold or mildew in the attic.
- Visible tears or deterioration if inspected.
- Granules or debris collecting under shingles.
Installation Process of Roofing Underlayment
- Preparation – Old shingles and underlayment removed, roof deck inspected.
- Deck Repairs – Damaged plywood or OSB replaced.
- Underlayment Application – Laid from the eaves upward, overlapping for waterproofing.
- Nail or Adhesive Fastening – Depending on material, nailed or self-sealed.
- Final Roof Installation – Shingles, tile, or metal roofing installed over underlayment.
Costs of Roofing Underlayment
While costs vary by region and material, here are average ranges:
- Asphalt Felt: $0.15 – $0.50 per sq. ft.
- Synthetic Underlayment: $0.20 – $0.75 per sq. ft.
- Rubberized Asphalt: $0.75 – $1.50 per sq. ft.
For a typical 2,000 sq. ft. roof:
- Felt: $300 – $1,000
- Synthetic: $400 – $1,500
- Rubberized: $1,500 – $3,000
Keep in mind this cost is for materials only. Labor is an additional expense.
Pros and Cons of Each Underlayment Type
Asphalt Felt
✅ Low cost
✅ Readily available
❌ Tears easily
❌ Shorter lifespan
Synthetic
✅ Durable and tear-resistant
✅ Lightweight for easy installation
✅ UV-resistant
❌ More expensive than felt
❌ Quality varies
Rubberized Asphalt
✅ Best waterproofing
✅ Great for vulnerable areas
✅ Self-sealing
❌ Very expensive
❌ Heavy, harder to work with
Underlayment for Different Roofing Materials
- Asphalt Shingles – Works with all underlayment types; synthetic is the most popular choice.
- Metal Roofs – Require heat-resistant synthetic or rubberized underlayment to withstand higher temperatures.
- Slate and Tile Roofs – Heavy materials that last decades need durable underlayment like premium synthetic or rubberized asphalt.
- Wood Shakes – Breathable synthetic underlayments work best.
Regional Considerations
- Hot Climates (Arizona, Nevada): Synthetic with heat resistance is best.
- Cold, Snowy Regions (Minnesota, New York): Rubberized asphalt protects against ice dams.
- Coastal Areas (Florida, Gulf States): Rubberized asphalt or premium synthetic withstand wind-driven rain.
- Mild Climates (California coast, Pacific Northwest): Asphalt felt may still be sufficient for budget installs.
Longevity and Maintenance
- Felt Underlayment: Lasts up to 15 years; check regularly in hot or stormy climates.
- Synthetic: Can last 20–40 years depending on quality.
- Rubberized Asphalt: Can outlast shingles, sometimes lasting 40+ years.
Although underlayment is hidden, its durability plays a huge role in roof performance.
Underlayment Myths Debunked
- “Underlayment isn’t necessary if shingles are good.”
False—shingles alone cannot fully protect your roof. - “All underlayment is the same.”
Different types vary greatly in cost, performance, and longevity. - “You can install new underlayment over old.”
Best practice is always to remove and replace old underlayment.
Future of Roofing Underlayment
With technology advancing, underlayment materials continue to improve. New synthetic blends promise longer lifespans, better fire resistance, and improved energy efficiency. In the future, we may see underlayments designed specifically to pair with solar panel installations or green roofs.
Conclusion
Selecting the best roofing underlayment is just as important as choosing the right shingles. Whether you opt for traditional asphalt felt, durable synthetic, or premium rubberized asphalt, the right choice depends on your budget, climate, and long-term goals.
Underlayment may be hidden beneath the surface, but it plays a huge role in preventing leaks, extending the life of your roof, and protecting your home’s structure. By investing in quality underlayment and proper installation, you ensure your roof can withstand weather challenges for decades to come. 440-235-3124
