(440) 307-2060
Can I Put New Shingles Over Old? What Homeowners Need to Know Before Roofing
Your roof is one of the most critical parts of your home — protecting you from the elements and enhancing curb appeal. When it’s time to replace your roof, you might wonder: Can I put new shingles over old shingles? This is a common question with important implications for cost, durability, and roofing performance.
In this detailed guide, we’ll explore everything you need to know about installing new shingles over old ones, including pros and cons, building code considerations, when it’s a good idea, when it isn’t, and best practices for a long-lasting roof. Whether you’re a homeowner planning a DIY project or preparing to talk to a contractor, this blog will help you make an informed decision.
What Does “Putting New Shingles Over Old” Mean?
When a roof replacement is needed, one option is to remove the existing shingles down to the roof deck before installing new shingles. This is called a tear-off.
Alternatively, some roofing contractors might suggest installing new shingles directly over the existing layer(s). This is known as a “roof overlay” or “reroofing.”
An overlay means you do not remove the old shingles first. Instead, you lay the new shingles on top, saving time and labor costs associated with tear-off.
How Many Layers of Shingles Are Allowed?
One key question is: How many layers of shingles can you have on your roof?
Building codes and manufacturers typically limit the number of shingle layers to prevent excessive weight on your roof structure and other problems.
- Most local building codes allow a maximum of two layers of asphalt shingles on a residential roof.
- Some areas may have stricter limits or require permits for overlays.
- Having more than two layers is generally not permitted and poses risks.
If your roof already has two layers, you will need to do a full tear-off before installing new shingles.
Advantages of Putting New Shingles Over Old
Why would someone consider laying new shingles over old?
1. Cost Savings
Removing old shingles means labor, disposal fees, and sometimes repair of damaged decking, which can add significantly to your total cost. Overlaying new shingles saves on these expenses.
2. Time Efficiency
Tear-offs can take a day or more depending on roof size and complexity. Installing shingles over the existing layer can speed up the process, minimizing disruption.
3. Less Mess and Disposal
No tear-off means no piles of old shingles to haul away, reducing cleanup and landfill fees.
Disadvantages of Installing New Shingles Over Old
While overlaying shingles might seem convenient, there are several drawbacks you should consider:
1. Hidden Damage
When you install new shingles over old ones, any existing damage to the roof decking, underlayment, or flashing remains hidden beneath the new layer. This can lead to problems like leaks and rot later on.
2. Shorter Roof Lifespan
New shingles installed over old ones may not last as long. The underlying layer can cause unevenness, reducing the new shingles’ ability to lay flat and properly shed water.
3. Added Weight on Roof Structure
Shingles are heavy. Adding a second layer doubles the weight, which could strain your roof framing, especially if it wasn’t designed for it.
4. Voided Warranty
Many roofing manufacturers void warranties if shingles are installed over an existing layer. This means you lose coverage in case of defects or early failure.
5. Resale Issues
When selling your home, a roof with multiple layers may raise concerns for buyers or home inspectors. Tear-offs allow a fresh, clean roof and documentation.
When Is It OK to Put New Shingles Over Old?
Overlaying shingles can be a reasonable option under the following conditions:
- Your roof currently has only one layer of shingles.
- The existing shingles are in good condition — no curling, missing pieces, or significant damage.
- The roof decking underneath is structurally sound with no rot or water damage.
- Your local building codes allow one overlay without a permit or inspection issues.
- You’re using compatible shingles — typically, asphalt over asphalt.
If these criteria are met, an overlay can be a cost-effective, quick way to extend your roof’s life by 10-15 years.
When Should You Avoid Installing New Shingles Over Old?
You should not overlay new shingles over existing ones if:
- Your roof already has two or more layers of shingles.
- The old shingles show signs of significant wear or damage like curling, cracking, or missing shingles.
- You notice signs of water damage or rot in the roof decking or attic.
- You live in a region with severe weather where maximum roof performance is critical.
- You plan to install a different type of roofing material (e.g., metal over shingles).
- You want to maintain or get a roofing warranty from the manufacturer.
In these cases, a full tear-off and replacement is the safer, longer-lasting choice.
How to Inspect Your Existing Roof Before Deciding
Before deciding whether to overlay or tear off, conduct a careful inspection of your roof’s current state:
- Look for damaged shingles — curled edges, missing tabs, cracks, or extensive granule loss.
- Inspect flashing, chimneys, vents, and gutters for leaks or rust.
- Check inside your attic for signs of leaks, water stains, mold, or daylight showing through.
- Assess the roof’s structural condition — sagging areas or soft spots may indicate decking issues.
If you’re unsure, hiring a professional roofing inspector can save you money and headaches in the long run.
Step-by-Step Process of Installing New Shingles Over Old
If you decide to install new shingles over old, here’s what typically happens:
Step 1: Roof Inspection and Preparation
The roofing crew inspects the existing shingles and roof deck for any visible damage.
Step 2: Clean the Roof Surface
Debris, moss, and dirt are cleared to ensure good adhesion of new shingles.
Step 3: Repair Minor Damage
Any minor repairs to flashing, vents, or decking are made.
Step 4: Install New Underlayment (Optional)
Some contractors may install a new layer of roofing felt or synthetic underlayment over the old shingles to improve waterproofing.
Step 5: Lay New Shingles
New shingles are installed according to manufacturer guidelines, carefully aligning them over the existing layer.
Step 6: Final Inspection and Cleanup
The roofing team checks their work and cleans up any leftover debris.
Cost Comparison: Overlay vs. Tear-Off
Here’s a rough estimate comparing costs:
| Type of Work | Average Cost per Square (100 sq. ft) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Tear-Off + New Roof | $350 – $550 | Includes labor, disposal, materials |
| Overlay + New Roof | $250 – $400 | Saves on removal and disposal |
Choosing overlay saves $100 to $150 per square on average, but consider the long-term value and risks.
Impact on Home Insurance and Resale Value
Insurance companies may have rules about multiple layers of roofing and could require a tear-off for coverage. Also, buyers and inspectors often prefer roofs with a single, fresh layer, which can improve resale value.
Environmental Considerations
Removing old shingles means sending them to a landfill unless they can be recycled. Overlaying reduces waste but potentially shortens roof life, leading to more frequent replacements. Discuss eco-friendly options with your contractor.
Alternatives to Overlaying Shingles
If overlaying isn’t right for your roof, consider:
- Complete Tear-Off and Replacement: The most thorough and durable option.
- Partial Roof Repairs: Fix damaged areas instead of full replacement if issues are localized.
- Roof Coatings or Sealants: In some cases, these can extend roof life temporarily.
Final Verdict: Can You Put New Shingles Over Old?
Yes, you can put new shingles over old ones under the right conditions—typically if you have one layer of sound asphalt shingles and local codes allow it. But in many cases, removing old shingles and starting fresh is the best way to ensure a long-lasting, trouble-free roof.
Always weigh the short-term savings of an overlay against the potential risks of hidden damage, reduced lifespan, and warranty issues. When in doubt, consult a licensed roofing professional.
FAQs About Putting New Shingles Over Old
Q: How long will a shingle overlay last?
A: Typically, 10-15 years, compared to 20-30 years for a full tear-off and new roof.
Q: Will my roof warranty be valid if I overlay?
A: Usually not. Most manufacturers require a full tear-off for warranty eligibility.
Q: Can I install a different type of shingle over old asphalt shingles?
A: No, overlays should only be done with the same shingle type, usually asphalt over asphalt.
Q: Does an overlay affect the weight on my roof?
A: Yes, adding a layer increases weight and may stress your roof framing.
Closing Thoughts
Replacing your roof is a significant investment and choosing the right method can save you money and hassle. While overlaying shingles can be tempting for cost and speed, it’s important to understand when it’s a suitable option and when it’s not.
Be sure to evaluate your roof’s condition carefully, consult local building codes, and seek expert advice. This way, you’ll make a roofing decision that protects your home and your budget for years to come.
