(440) 307-2060
The Definitive Guide to Composition Shingles
Composition shingles—also referred to interchangeably as composite shingles or asphalt shingles—are by far the most popular residential roofing option, valued for their balance of affordability, durability, and curb appeal.
Let’s explore what they are, how they work, their types, pros and cons, maintenance tips, cost considerations, and how to choose the right kind for your home.
What Are Composition Shingles?
Composition shingles are multi-layered roofing panels made of:
- Fiberglass or cellulose mat as the core for stability and strength
- Asphalt coating that provides water resistance and flexibility
- Mineral granules on the surface, which add UV protection, color, and fire resistance
These layers come together to form shingles that can endure various weather conditions while offering aesthetic versatility.
A Brief History
Asphalt shingles have evolved since their invention in 1903. Originally made with a felt base (often cotton rag), they later transitioned to fiberglass mats for improved durability and fire resistance Today, manufacturers continue refining these systems for strength, longevity, and environmental performance.
Types of Composition Shingles
Composition shingles generally fall into three categories:
- 3‑Tab Shingles
- Flat, single-layer construction with uniform “tabs”
- Most budget-friendly
- Lifespan: 15–25 years with proper maintenance
- Architectural (Dimensional / Laminated) Shingles
- Multiple asphalt-coated layers, offering a textured, dimensional look
- Mid-range cost, better wind and impact resistance
- Lifespan: around 25–30 years
- Luxury (Designer / Premium) Shingles
- Thicker, heavier, and styled to resemble premium materials like slate or wood shake
- Higher upfront cost, long life expectancy (up to 50 years)
Benefits of Composition Shingles
1. Cost‑Effectiveness
Composition shingles are generally more affordable than materials like metal, tile, or slate
2. Versatility in Design
Available in a broad spectrum of colors, textures, and styles—from classic asphalt looks to wood or slate
3. Durability & Weather Resistance
They perform well under rain, wind, UV exposure, and even hail (especially impact-resistant variations). Many come with Class‑A fire ratings and high impact ratings
4. Ease of Installation & Repair
Lighter weight and straightforward installation make them accessible to most roofing contractors; individual shingles can be replaced with minimal disruption .
5. Energy Efficiency & Insurance Savings
Light-colored varieties can reflect sunlight, lowering cooling costs by 7–15%. Impact-resistant shingles may qualify for insurance discounts up to 35%.
6. Eco‑Friendly Aspects
Recyclable shingles and higher manufacturing standards make composition shingles increasingly sustainable
Drawbacks to Be Aware Of
Shorter Service Life Compared to Premium Materials
While durable, they don’t match the 50–100+ year lifespan of slate, tile, or metal panels
Potential for Algae or Moss Growth
Especially in humid or shaded areas. Regular cleaning helps, but growth can affect appearance and roof health
Environmental Considerations
Although recyclable, they are petroleum-derived products. Their environmental footprint remains a concern compared to more sustainable materials.
Susceptibility to Damage
Hail, strong winds, or temperature extremes can cause granule loss, curling, or cracking over time
Maintenance & Care Tips
- Inspect Regularly
Check for missing, cracked, or curling shingles, especially after storms. - Clean Carefully
Remove debris; treat algae or mold with appropriate cleaners—avoid pressure washing, which can damage shingles , . - Maintain Gutters
Clean gutters help prevent water backup and edge damage - Replace Damaged Shingles Promptly
Addressing issues early helps protect the overall roof system. - Understand Warranties
Manufacturer warranties often span 20–50 years, but tend to be pro-rated. Installers may offer separate workmanship guarantees
Cost Considerations & Long‑Term Value
- Installation Costs: Expect $3–$5 per square foot (materials + labor). Upfront, a 2,000 sq ft roof can range $6,000–$10,000, depending on shingle type (
- Lifespan & Value: Architectural and premium options reduce maintenance and may last up to 50 years, improving long-term ROI Spruce).
- Energy & Insurance Savings: Reflective shingles help cut cooling costs; impact-resistant shingles can reduce insurance premiums Roofing).
How to Choose Composition Shingles for Your Home
Considerations include:
- Budget: 3‑tab = budget-friendly; architectural or luxury = higher initial investment.
- Aesthetic Goals: Deeper textures and shadow lines give a more refined look.
- Climate: Choose impact-rated or algae-resistant shingles in hail-prone or humid regions.
- Resale Value: Architectural or premium shingles improve curb appeal and marketability.
- Warranty and Installer Reputation: Evaluate both product and workmanship coverage.
Experts recommend coordinating color and style with your home’s architectural and exterior palette for a cohesive visual impact
Final Thoughts
Composition shingles continue to dominate residential roofing because they balance performance, aesthetics, and affordability. Whether you’re building new or replacing an aging roof, understanding the options—from 3‑tab to luxury designer shingles—empowers you to make informed decisions for your home’s long-term durability and value.
