(440) 307-2060
Difference Between Asphalt And Composite Shingles
When homeowners begin thinking about replacing their roof, one of the first questions is what material to choose. Asphalt shingles have been around for generations, while newer composite shingles are steadily growing in popularity. The difference between asphalt and composite shingles lies in their cost, lifespan, appearance, and performance in different climates. Understanding these contrasts will help you decide which option works best for your home, your budget, and your long-term plans.
What Makes Asphalt Shingles Unique?
Asphalt shingles are by far the most widely used roofing material in North America. They are made from a fiberglass or organic mat that is coated in asphalt and covered with protective granules. The result is a lightweight, affordable, and reliable product that has been trusted for decades.
There are three main categories:
- Three-tab shingles – flat, uniform, and budget-friendly.
- Architectural shingles – thicker, dimensional, and more durable.
- Designer shingles – premium options that mimic wood, slate, or tile.
If you’d like to dive deeper into each category and understand their unique strengths, you can read more in [Asphalt Shingle Types]. That guide explains how three-tab shingles remain the most economical choice but sacrifice some durability, while architectural shingles strike a balance of strength and style. Designer shingles push things even further, giving homeowners the ability to replicate the look of slate or clay tile without the heavy weight. Knowing these distinctions helps you choose the right shingle for your budget and design goals.
What Makes Composite Shingles Different?
Composite shingles, sometimes referred to as synthetic shingles, are manufactured with a mix of advanced materials such as polymers, plastics, and recycled components. They’re designed to replicate the appearance of slate, cedar shakes, or even asphalt, but with better durability and weather resistance.
Many composite shingles come with high impact and fire ratings, making them a strong option in areas with harsh storms or wildfire concerns. Because they are engineered products, they also resist fading and cracking better than asphalt.
If you’ve ever wondered how composites compare to traditional cedar shakes, you may find [What is a Shake Roof ]helpful. That piece explains how natural shake roofs provide a rustic, textured look that many homeowners love. However, shakes require regular treatments to prevent rot, mold, and insect damage. Composite shingles that mimic shakes give you the same charm without the maintenance hassles, making them a smart alternative for those who admire the look of wood but want longer performance.
Cost Considerations
Cost is one of the first details homeowners want to compare. Asphalt shingles are typically more affordable up front. Their materials are inexpensive, and installation is quick since nearly every roofing contractor is familiar with the process.
Composite shingles, on the other hand, are a premium material. They often require a higher upfront investment for both materials and labor. Still, they can save money in the long run because they last longer and usually require fewer repairs.
For homeowners weighing other choices beyond asphalt and composite, a full [Roof Materials List] is worth exploring. That overview compares options like metal, tile, and wood, giving you insight into how different roofing materials perform over time. Looking at the big picture can help you understand where asphalt and composite fall on the spectrum of cost and durability compared to alternatives.
Lifespan and Durability
Longevity is where composite shingles often shine.
- Asphalt shingles typically last 15–30 years depending on the style and climate. Three-tab shingles wear out faster, while architectural shingles hold up longer.
- Composite shingles can last 40–50 years or more. Premium products often carry extended warranties because they’re built to withstand wind, hail, and extreme temperatures.
If you’d like more detailed information on how asphalt shingles perform over time, check out [Lifespan of Asphalt Shingle Roof]. That resource explains how factors like climate, installation quality, and ventilation can shorten or extend the life of asphalt roofs. It also highlights how maintenance, such as keeping gutters clean and addressing small leaks quickly, can help asphalt shingles reach their maximum potential lifespan.
Appearance and Style
Curb appeal plays a huge role in roofing decisions.
- Asphalt shingles are available in many colors, and architectural versions provide a layered look. Still, their appearance is familiar and sometimes less distinctive.
- Composite shingles are engineered to replicate natural materials with impressive realism. From the street, many look almost identical to real slate or cedar but without the maintenance headaches.
For those choosing between asphalt’s most common variations, [Three Tab vs Architectural Shingles] can help you visualize the differences. That comparison shows how three-tab shingles create a uniform, flat look while architectural shingles add dimension and a more modern aesthetic. Homeowners who value a budget-friendly option may still lean toward three-tabs, but those who want their home to stand out often choose architectural styles for their depth and variety of shades.
Installation Considerations
Most roofers are experienced with asphalt shingles, making installation quick and efficient. Composite shingles may require a contractor who understands their unique fastening and ventilation needs. While not overly complicated, the process is slightly different.
Roof slope also plays an important role in determining whether shingles are the right choice. If you want to understand the limits and safe practices, the guide on [Minimum Roof Slope for Shingles] explains the standards professionals follow. Low-slope roofs, for example, may require additional underlayment or even a completely different roofing material to prevent leaks. Learning about slope requirements ensures your roof will perform as expected for decades.
Performance in Harsh Weather
Roofing performance is closely tied to climate:
- Hot regions: asphalt shingles can lose granules and become brittle. Composite shingles typically hold up better under strong UV rays.
- Cold regions: asphalt shingles may crack in freezing temperatures, while composites are engineered to stay flexible.
- Storm-prone areas: composite shingles often carry high impact ratings that help resist hail and flying debris.
Even with durable products, occasional problems are unavoidable. If you ever find water seeping into your attic or ceilings, you can follow the steps in [How to Fix Leaking Roof]. That guide provides practical instructions for spotting the source of leaks, applying temporary fixes, and knowing when it’s time to call a professional. Being proactive with small leaks can prevent costly structural damage.
Environmental Factors
Asphalt shingles are petroleum-based and more difficult to recycle. They also need to be replaced more often, contributing to landfill waste. Composite shingles often contain recycled materials and have longer lifespans, making them more environmentally friendly overall.
Energy Efficiency
Both asphalt and composite shingles can be manufactured with reflective properties that help reduce heat absorption. Light colors and specialized granules can improve energy efficiency, but composite shingles sometimes offer better long-term performance since they resist fading and maintain their reflectivity longer.
Maintenance and Repairs
All roofs need care, but maintenance differs:
- Asphalt shingles: prone to curling, cracking, or losing granules with age.
- Composite shingles: less likely to deteriorate quickly, which means fewer repairs over decades of use.
Routine inspections still matter for both, especially after storms.
Resale Value and Aesthetics
Buyers often value a long-lasting, attractive roof. Composite shingles may increase resale value because of their premium look and extended warranties. Asphalt shingles remain widely accepted but don’t usually carry the same upscale appeal.
Alternative Choices
Some homeowners decide to go in a completely different direction and install a metal roof instead. In fact, it’s possible to place metal panels directly over existing shingles in certain situations. If you’re curious about that process, the article on [Installing Metal Roof Over Shingles] explains how it’s done and what factors to consider. It covers structural requirements, pros and cons, and why some homeowners choose this route for energy efficiency and durability.
Summing It Up
The difference between asphalt and composite shingles boils down to balancing short-term affordability with long-term value. Asphalt shingles are accessible, cost-effective, and familiar. Composite shingles offer durability, style, and longevity for those willing to invest more upfront.
Your decision will depend on your budget, the climate where you live, and how long you plan to stay in your home.
Conclusion
The roof is one of the most important features of any home. Asphalt shingles remain the go-to choice for many because of their affordability and availability, while composite shingles appeal to homeowners looking for strength, beauty, and extended service life.
By considering cost, appearance, lifespan, installation, and environmental impact, you’ll be able to make an informed choice that fits your goals. Whether you value immediate savings or long-term protection, knowing the difference between asphalt and composite shingles ensures you’ll select the right roof for your home. 440-235-3124
