Metal Roofing Over Shingles

by S&K Construction And Remodeling | Jul 23, 2025 | Uncategorized

🏠 Metal Roofing Over Shingles: A Comprehensive 2025 Homeowner’s Guide

SEO Keywords: metal roof over shingles, metal over shingles pros and cons, cost of metal roof over shingles, can you put metal over shingles

1. What It Means to Install a Metal Roof Over Shingles

Installing a metal roof over asphalt shingles means leaving the existing shingle layer intact and attaching new metal panels directly on top. This “overlay” approach can save time, disposal fees, and reduce waste—but also introduces unique risks related to waterproofing, ventilation, and structural integrity. (theamishroofer.com, RPS Metal Roofing & Siding, Inc., Rescue My Roof, The Spruce)

2. Top Benefits of Metal‑Over‑Shingles Installation

✔ Cost Savings

By not removing old shingles, you save $1–2 per sq ft in tear-off and disposal fees—translating to $1,000–$3,000 saved on a typical roof. (New England Metal Roofing, All Around Roofing, Siding & Gutters)

✔ Faster & Less Disruptive Installation

Without demolition, installation proceeds quickly, causes fewer interior disruptions, and leaves your yard cleaner. (Rescue My Roof, All Around Roofing, Siding & Gutters)

✔ Added Thermal & Weather Layer

The existing shingles may act as minor insulation and backup waterproofing beneath the metal. (Rescue My Roof)

✔ Environmental Benefits

Avoiding shingle disposal helps reduce landfill waste, and many metal roofs are made from recycled materials. (theamishroofer.com)

✔ New Roof Longevity

Metal roofs typically last 40–70 years even when installed over shingles—offering extended performance. (theamishroofer.com)

3. Major Drawbacks & Concerns

❌ Hidden Deck Damage

You lose access to the roof decking to inspect or replace rotted or damaged boards, which may lead to undetected issues later. (Bill Ragan Roofing)

❌ Added Weight

Even though metal is lighter than shingles, the combined load may stress rafters and shift roof structure—especially in older homes. (Reddit)

❌ Moisture & Ventilation Issues

Trapped moisture between layers, especially in humid climates, can cause mold, corroding fasteners, and shorten roof lifespan. (O’Donnell Roofing Co., All Around Roofing, Siding & Gutters, Pally Roofing)

❌ Uneven Surface Challenges

Asphalt shingles create an uneven substrate, making it difficult to achieve a flat, waveless metal install and potentially leading to loose fasteners over time. (O’Donnell Roofing Co.)

❌ Warranty and Insurance Risks

Many manufacturer warranties do not cover over-shingle installations. Insurance may deny claims tied to improper installations. Always confirm legality and warranty details. (New England Metal Roofing)

❌ Long-Term Cost and Maintenance

What seems like short-term savings can lead to higher maintenance costs and earlier failure versus a full tear-off and properly installed metal roof. (theamishroofer.com)

4. Cost Comparison: Metal Over vs Tear-Off

Installation Method	Avg Cost per sq ft	Tear-Off Savings	Disposal Costs
Metal over shingles	$8–$14	~$1–$2/sq ft	Minimal
Metal after tear-off	$9–$15	None	$1,000–$2,500 (for debris)

Cost savings vary by metal type and complexity—but note that manufacturer-recommended warranties often apply only to tear-off installs. (New England Metal Roofing)

5. Ventilation & Moisture Control Best Practices

Proper ventilation is essential:

Use high-temperature synthetic underlayment or ice & water shield beneath metal, even over shingles. (New England Metal Roofing)
Leave an air gap between shingles and metal using furring strips or battens to promote airflow and prevent condensation. (Wikipedia)
Install ridge vents and soffit vents to maintain air exchange; trapped moisture may cause rot and void warranties. (Pally Roofing)

6. Structural, Code & Warranty Considerations

Many jurisdictions limit roof layering to two total layers—if there are already two asphalt layers, you’ll need a tear-off. Check local code. (Rescue My Roof)
Confirm that your roof framing can handle the combined load of shingles and metal—especially in snow regions. (O’Donnell Roofing Co., Jeff Woods Construction & Roofing)
Ask if metal roof manufacturer allows over-shingle installation; if not compliant, that may void your warranty. (O’Donnell Roofing Co.)

7. Installation Techniques & Advice

Professional installer required: Ensure they’re experienced with overlays and certified to avoid fastener failures or oil-canning. (Reddit, Jeff Woods Construction & Roofing)
Install furring strips (“sleepers”) level over shingles before fastening the metal panels for uniform surface and ventilation. (Reddit, Reddit)
Select a high-temp underlayment rated for metal over asphalt to prevent chemical reactions between roofing layers. (New England Metal Roofing)
Use concealed fastener systems or correct roofing screws, and follow panel manufacturer spacing. (New England Metal Roofing, Pally Roofing)

8. Real-World Experience from Homeowners

🗣 Reddit Feedback

“It’s common where I live.… ran strapping over the shingles and installed—the roof’s held for 21 years.” (Reddit)

“All projects we’ve inspected later had leaks after storms. Metal over shingles always leaks eventually, especially after storms.” — experienced adjuster. (Reddit)

“Condensation slowly causes corrosion… only top benefit is price.” — roofing veteran. (Reddit)

These diverse experiences highlight that proper installation and existing roof condition are crucial determinants of success.

9. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: Can you put metal over shingles?
A: Yes—if local codes permit only two total layers and your decking is in good condition.

Q: Will it void my warranty?
A: Possibly—many manufacturers and insurers limit coverage for metal installed over asphalt shingles if not to their specs. (theamishroofer.com, New England Metal Roofing)

Q: Is it noisy during rain?
A: Not necessarily. With proper insulation and high-temp underlayment, metal overlay roofs can be as quiet as shingle roofs. (New England Metal Roofing, Reddit)

Q: Do I need underlayment over shingles?
A: Yes. High-temperature synthetic or ice shield underlayment is strongly recommended and often required. (New England Metal Roofing, Pally Roofing)

Q: How long will the metal roof last?
A: A well-installed metal roof typically lasts 40–70 years—even over shingles. Life expectancy may drop if moisture accumulates. (Pally Roofing, theamishroofer.com)

10. Conclusion & Decision Checklist

✅ Steel-over-Shingles Decision Checklist:

Check local code: only 1 existing layer allowed
Roof deck must be inspected and in sound condition
Use proper underlayment and ventilation strategy
Ensure installer has certification and overlay experience
Confirm manufacturer warranty allows overlay installation
Include furring strips or air space for condensation prevention
Budget savings must be compared with long-term risk & ROI

Installing a metal roof over shingles can save time, cut waste, and reduce upfront costs—but carries added risk. The overlay method works best when roof structure is solid, moisture control is robust, and professional contractors follow manufacturer guidelines. When done improperly, what seems like a savings can lead to hidden problems and voided warranties.

If you need help evaluating your roof’s condition, choosing the right installer in your area, or comparing overlay and tear-off cost estimates, I’d be happy to help.

Our Recent Blog & Articles

What It Means to Be a Certified Owens Corning Duration® Shingles Contractor

More Blogs & Articles