(440) 307-2060
Metal vs Asphalt Roof: A Complete Guide for Homeowners
When deciding on a new roof, understanding the differences between a metal vs asphalt roof is critical. Both options are popular for residential homes, but they offer distinct benefits, costs, and maintenance requirements. Choosing the right type can affect the durability, energy efficiency, aesthetic appeal, and long-term value of your home. Homeowners need to weigh factors like lifespan, performance in different climates, upfront cost, and maintenance to make an informed choice.
This guide explores metal and asphalt roofing in detail, comparing their materials, advantages, disadvantages, installation, maintenance, and cost considerations. By the end, homeowners will have a clear understanding of how metal vs asphalt roof options perform and how to select the best fit for their property.
Understanding Metal and Asphalt Roofs
Metal Roofs
Metal roofing is made from materials such as steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc. It can come in panels, shingles, or tiles and is known for its durability and energy efficiency.
Key Features of Metal Roofs:
- Lightweight but strong
- Long lifespan (40–70 years depending on material)
- Fire-resistant and wind-resistant
- Can be coated to reflect sunlight and improve energy efficiency
Asphalt Roofs
Asphalt roofing is the most common material for residential homes in North America. It is made from fiberglass or organic mats coated with asphalt and granules. Asphalt shingles are available as standard 3-tab or architectural (dimensional) styles.
Key Features of Asphalt Roofs:
- Affordable and widely available
- Lifespan of 20–30 years for 3-tab, 30–50 years for architectural shingles
- Variety of colors and textures to match home style
- Easier and faster to install compared to metal panels
Comparing Metal vs Asphalt Roof: Advantages
Advantages of Metal Roofs
- Longevity
Metal roofs can last several decades longer than asphalt shingles, reducing the need for frequent replacements. - Durability
Metal resists cracking, shrinking, and eroding, and is highly resistant to hail, fire, and high winds. - Energy Efficiency
Reflective coatings reduce heat absorption, lowering cooling costs in hot climates. - Lightweight
Metal panels are lighter than asphalt, reducing stress on the roof structure. - Low Maintenance
Requires minimal upkeep, with occasional inspections and cleaning.
Advantages of Asphalt Roofs
- Cost-Effective
Asphalt shingles have a lower upfront cost compared to metal roofing, making them ideal for budget-conscious homeowners. - Variety
Available in numerous colors, styles, and textures to complement different home designs. - Ease of Installation
Asphalt shingles are easier and quicker to install, which can reduce labor costs. - Repairability
Damaged shingles can be replaced individually without replacing the entire roof. - Sound Insulation
Asphalt shingles naturally absorb sound, reducing noise from rain or hail compared to metal roofs.
Comparing Metal vs Asphalt Roof: Disadvantages
Disadvantages of Metal Roofs
- Higher Upfront Cost
The initial investment for metal roofing is significantly higher than asphalt shingles. - Noise
Rain, hail, or debris hitting a metal roof can be noisy unless proper insulation is installed. - Expansion and Contraction
Metal expands and contracts with temperature changes, potentially loosening fasteners over time. - Installation Complexity
Requires specialized skills for proper installation, making DIY installation challenging.
Disadvantages of Asphalt Roofs
- Shorter Lifespan
Asphalt shingles typically need replacement every 20–30 years, depending on quality and climate. - Prone to Weather Damage
High winds, hail, and extreme temperature fluctuations can damage asphalt shingles. - Maintenance Requirements
May require repairs after storms, and granule loss can reduce lifespan. - Environmental Impact
Asphalt shingles are petroleum-based and contribute to landfill waste when replaced.
Cost Comparison: Metal vs Asphalt Roof
Metal Roof Costs
- Material cost: $5–$12 per square foot, depending on metal type (steel, aluminum, copper)
- Installation: Labor costs may increase total to $7–$15 per square foot
- Long-term value: High durability reduces replacement costs over decades
Asphalt Roof Costs
- Material cost: $3–$7 per square foot for standard shingles
- Installation: Labor costs bring total to $5–$9 per square foot
- Long-term value: Lower upfront cost but more frequent replacement may increase lifetime cost
Cost Summary
| Feature | Metal Roof | Asphalt Roof |
|---|---|---|
| Material Cost | $5–$12/sq.ft. | $3–$7/sq.ft. |
| Installation Cost | $7–$15/sq.ft. | $5–$9/sq.ft. |
| Lifespan | 40–70 years | 20–50 years |
| Maintenance | Low | Moderate |
Installation Considerations
Metal Roof Installation
- Requires specialized panels or shingles and precise fastening
- Proper underlayment and ventilation are crucial
- Flashing and trim must be installed carefully to prevent leaks
- Installation may take longer than asphalt shingles
Asphalt Roof Installation
- Easier to install for standard homes
- Requires roofing felt or synthetic underlayment
- Shingles are nailed to roof decking
- Installation is faster, usually completed in a few days for standard homes
Maintenance and Longevity
Metal Roof Maintenance
- Inspect for loose fasteners, corrosion, or dents annually
- Clean debris to prevent water buildup
- Minimal repairs required compared to asphalt
Asphalt Roof Maintenance
- Inspect after storms for missing or damaged shingles
- Replace individual shingles when damaged
- Clean gutters to prevent water damage and moss growth
Energy Efficiency: Metal vs Asphalt Roof
- Metal Roof: Reflective coatings can reduce cooling costs by 10–25% in hot climates
- Asphalt Roof: Light-colored or reflective shingles improve energy efficiency, though less than metal
- Proper attic insulation benefits both types
Aesthetic Considerations
- Metal Roof: Modern, sleek, or can mimic other materials such as slate or tile; available in panels or shingles
- Asphalt Roof: Versatile colors and textures; architectural shingles provide depth and dimensionality
Environmental Considerations
- Metal Roof: Often contains recycled materials and is fully recyclable at the end of its life
- Asphalt Roof: Petroleum-based, contributes to landfill waste, less environmentally friendly
Weather Performance: Metal vs Asphalt Roof
- Wind: Metal panels can withstand higher wind speeds than asphalt shingles
- Hail: Metal is more resistant to impact; asphalt can crack or lose granules
- Snow and Ice: Metal sheds snow and ice efficiently; asphalt may need additional insulation to prevent ice dams
- Fire: Metal is non-combustible; asphalt shingles vary in fire rating
Choosing Between Metal vs Asphalt Roof
Questions to Ask Yourself:
- What is my budget for upfront costs and long-term maintenance?
- How long do I plan to stay in my home?
- What is the local climate, and what weather challenges does my area face?
- How important is energy efficiency and sustainability to me?
- Do I prefer a traditional look or a modern aesthetic?
Common Misconceptions
- Metal Roofs Are Too Noisy
Proper insulation significantly reduces noise from rain or hail. - Asphalt Shingles Are Always Cheaper Long-Term
Frequent replacement and maintenance can increase total cost over decades. - Metal Roofs Require Extensive Maintenance
Metal roofs are low-maintenance compared to asphalt. - Asphalt Shingles Cannot Withstand Extreme Weather
High-quality architectural shingles can perform well under wind, rain, and moderate hail.
Conclusion
Choosing between a metal vs asphalt roof involves evaluating cost, durability, aesthetics, energy efficiency, maintenance, and environmental impact. Metal roofs provide long-term durability, energy savings, and low maintenance but come with a higher upfront cost. Asphalt shingles are affordable, easy to install, and versatile in design, but they require more maintenance and have a shorter lifespan.
Homeowners should consider their budget, climate, home design, and long-term plans when selecting a roof. Consulting with a professional roofer can ensure proper installation and help weigh the benefits of each material. By understanding the advantages, disadvantages, and performance of metal and asphalt roofs, homeowners can make an informed decision that protects their home and adds lasting value.440-235-3124
