Scalloped Roof Shingles: What Is This Decorative Asphalt Shingle Style?
When choosing roofing materials for your home, the style and design of the roof can significantly impact the overall aesthetic appeal of your property. While functionality is the primary concern, roofing materials also offer opportunities to enhance the architectural beauty of your home. One roofing style that has gained popularity for its decorative charm is scalloped roof shingles. These shingles add a unique, elegant look to any roof and have become a go-to option for homeowners who want a visually distinct and classic appearance when getting a new roof installed. Choosing the right materials is an important part of any roof installation.
In this blog, we’ll explore what scalloped roof shingles are, their benefits, installation considerations, and why they are an excellent choice for homeowners looking to elevate the curb appeal of their property. Whether you’re building a new home or replacing an existing roof, understanding the appeal of scalloped shingles can help you make an informed decision about your roofing style.Working with a professional roofing contractor can help you select the best option for your home.
If you want something different from a standard architectural shingle, premium and designer asphalt shingles can give your home a more distinctive roofline while maintaining the benefits of a modern asphalt roofing system.
S&K Construction And Remodeling LLC provides asphalt shingle roof replacement, designer roofing options, roof inspections, and roofing estimates throughout Northeast Ohio.
Schedule a free roof inspection and estimate today.
What Are Scalloped Roof Shingles?
Scalloped roof shingles are a type of decorative asphalt shingle that features a rounded, curve-like edge, resembling the shape of a scallop shell. These shingles are designed to create a unique, visually attractive roofline by adding a soft, flowing edge to the roof. Typically, scalloped shingles are manufactured from asphalt, which is the most common material used for residential roofs due to its durability, affordability, and ease of installation. Asphalt shingles are one of the most common materials used in roof replacement projects.
The scalloped design offers a striking, textured appearance, and it is often chosen for its vintage or cottage-style appeal. This style of shingle is not only beautiful but also highly functional. Scalloped shingles are available in various colors and finishes, allowing homeowners to tailor their roofs to complement the existing architecture and color scheme of their home.These design choices are often discussed during a roofing estimate.
While scalloped shingles are most commonly associated with more traditional, historic, or whimsical homes, they can also be used effectively on modern homes with the right design approach. They are often found on homes that feature steep or sloping roofs, as the curvature of the shingles helps enhance the visual appeal of the roof’s angles.
Types of Scalloped Roof Shingles
There are several types of scalloped roof shingles, each with its own distinct look and benefits. The most common types include:Selecting the right style is an important step in planning your roofing project.
1. Traditional Scalloped Shingles
These shingles have a classic, rounded edge, offering a soft, curved appearance. They are often used for homes with a vintage, cottage, or Victorian style. Traditional scalloped shingles are typically installed in rows, creating a layered effect that highlights the curves and edges.
2. Hexagonal Scalloped Shingles
Hexagonal scalloped shingles are designed with a geometric twist. Instead of a fully rounded edge, these shingles have a more defined, angular scallop that creates a distinctive honeycomb-like pattern. This style is perfect for homeowners looking for a more modern take on the classic scalloped look.
3. Mansard Scalloped Shingles
Mansard scalloped shingles are a variation designed for roofs with a mansard shape, which has steep slopes on all sides. The scalloped edges of these shingles help enhance the visual impact of mansard roofs, which are often used in French-inspired architecture.
4. Modified Scalloped Shingles
Modified scalloped shingles are a hybrid between traditional scalloped shingles and standard architectural shingles. These shingles incorporate some degree of curve, but the overall design is slightly less pronounced. Modified scalloped shingles often offer the look of scallops without the pronounced effect, which may be preferred by homeowners who want a subtler design.
Each of these variations can be customized to fit the aesthetic preferences of homeowners, providing a wide range of options for different architectural styles and roofing needs.
Benefits of Scalloped Roof Shingles
Choosing scalloped roof shingles goes beyond just visual appeal. These shingles offer several key benefits that make them an excellent choice for homeowners. Let’s explore some of the top advantages of opting for scalloped asphalt shingles:
1. Aesthetic Appeal
Scalloped roof shingles provide a distinctive and charming look that sets a home apart from others. The curves and texture of the shingles can evoke a sense of timeless elegance, making them ideal for historical, vintage, or cottage-style homes. The scalloped edges add depth and dimension to the roofline, contributing to an overall sense of visual interest and character. A well-designed roof can significantly improve your overall roofing system.
Whether you want your home to blend in with the neighborhood or stand out as a unique design, scalloped shingles offer a range of aesthetic possibilities.
2. Durability and Longevity
Despite their decorative nature, scalloped shingles are made from durable asphalt, a material known for its strength and resilience. Asphalt shingles, including scalloped ones, are designed to withstand a variety of weather conditions, including heavy rain, wind, and hail. With proper installation and maintenance, scalloped shingles can last for 20-30 years, providing long-term protection for your home.Proper installation is key to maximizing the lifespan of your roof installation.
Additionally, scalloped asphalt shingles are typically resistant to UV rays, preventing them from fading or deteriorating quickly when exposed to sunlight.
3. Enhanced Curb Appeal
The unique look of scalloped shingles can significantly boost your home’s curb appeal. Whether you’re looking to sell your home or simply want to enhance its appearance, a roof with scalloped shingles can create a more appealing and distinctive visual profile. Homes with scalloped roofing often stand out in the neighborhood, offering a classic yet modern appeal.Upgrading materials like this is a common part of a roof replacement
Potential buyers are likely to be attracted to the charm of a scalloped roof, especially in areas where traditional, whimsical, or historic architecture is appreciated.
4. Variety of Styles and Colors
Scalloped shingles come in a wide array of colors, textures, and finishes, making it easy to choose a style that complements the rest of your home’s exterior. Whether you prefer a natural look with earthy tones or a more vibrant finish that matches your home’s trim, scalloped shingles can be customized to match your design preferences. This versatility allows homeowners to create a cohesive and polished exterior that reflects their personal style.
Cost-Effectiveness
While scalloped shingles offer an upscale, decorative appearance, they remain an affordable roofing option compared to other premium roofing materials like slate or cedar shakes. The combination of durability, aesthetic appeal, and cost-effectiveness makes scalloped shingles a great choice for homeowners who want to invest in a roof that looks great without breaking the bank.
6. Easy Maintenance
Maintaining scalloped shingles is relatively easy compared to other types of decorative roofing materials. Asphalt shingles, in general, require less maintenance than other materials like wood or metal. Periodic roof inspections and cleaning will help maintain the appearance and integrity of the roof, preventing issues such as mold or algae growth.Incorrect installation can lead to future roof repair issues.Local expertise is important when planning a roofing project in Northeast Ohio.
As long as the shingles are properly installed and cared for, they can continue to perform well and retain their charm for many years.
Installation Considerations for Scalloped Roof Shingles
While scalloped roof shingles are a fantastic choice for enhancing your home’s curb appeal, it’s essential to understand some of the installation considerations before making your decision. Proper installation is crucial to ensuring the longevity and effectiveness of your roof, so it’s important to hire an experienced contractor who understands the unique requirements of scalloped shingles.Hiring an experienced roofing contractor ensures proper alignment and performance.
1. Roof Slope
Scalloped shingles are best suited for homes with a moderate to steep roof slope. The design of the shingles is meant to enhance the angles of a pitched roof, so they may not be as effective on flat or low-slope roofs. If your home has a flat roof, you may want to consider other roofing materials that can provide a more functional solution.
2. Professional Installation
Installing scalloped shingles requires skill and precision to ensure that the curves and patterns are properly aligned. It’s essential to hire a professional roofing contractor who is experienced with scalloped shingle installation. If the shingles are not installed correctly, it could lead to uneven patterns or gaps that affect the aesthetic and functionality of the roof.
3. Climate Considerations
While scalloped shingles are durable, it’s important to consider the climate in your area. For example, if you live in an area with extreme temperatures or frequent storms, you may need to take extra precautions to ensure the shingles can withstand these conditions. Your roofing contractor can advise you on the best materials and installation techniques for your specific climate.
4. Cost of Installation
The cost of installing scalloped shingles will typically be higher than that of standard asphalt shingles due to the labor-intensive process involved in creating the scalloped edges and the additional materials required for a decorative design. However, this cost is often offset by the long-term durability and enhanced curb appeal the shingles provide.Costs can vary depending on the details included in your roof estimate.
What Are Scalloped Roof Shingles?
Scalloped shingles are decorative roofing shingles designed with rounded, cut-away, or patterned lower edges instead of the straight appearance associated with many traditional asphalt shingles.
The style is commonly associated with historic, Victorian, cottage, and slate-inspired architecture.
Modern luxury asphalt shingles can reproduce this decorative appearance without requiring a traditional natural slate roofing system.
Are Scalloped Shingles Made From Asphalt?
Some modern scalloped-style roofing products are manufactured as asphalt shingles.
They use asphalt, reinforcement, and mineral granules like other asphalt roofing products but feature a more decorative shape and layered appearance.
For example, CertainTeed’s Carriage House is currently marketed as a luxury asphalt shingle with a scalloped cut designed to mimic natural slate.
Are Scalloped Shingles the Same as Architectural Shingles?
Not exactly.
Architectural or dimensional shingles are a broad category of laminated asphalt roofing products.
Scalloped-style shingles are generally more decorative and may fall into the premium or luxury asphalt shingle category depending on the manufacturer and product.
CertainTeed separates standard dimensional products from luxury shingles such as Carriage House and Grand Manor.
What Do Scalloped Shingles Look Like?
Scalloped shingles create a patterned roof edge that can resemble old-world slate, decorative Victorian roofing, or other historic roof designs.
Depending on the product, the lower edge may appear rounded, cut away, or chamfered.
The pattern becomes especially noticeable on:
Steep roof slopes
Gables
Turrets
Dormers
Mansard-style roof sections
Large visible roof planes
This makes the style primarily an architectural choice rather than a separate roofing system.
What Homes Look Best With Scalloped Shingles?
Scalloped or slate-inspired shingles can work particularly well on homes with strong architectural character.
Examples include:
Victorian homes
Historic homes
Cottage-style houses
Tudor-inspired homes
Homes with turrets
Homes with steep gables
Mansard roof designs
Luxury residential homes
The roofing style should still complement the siding, trim, masonry, windows, and overall architecture of the home.
Are Scalloped Roof Shingles Still Available?
Yes, scalloped-style asphalt roofing products are still available, although homeowners should not assume that every manufacturer offers them.
Availability can change by manufacturer, product line, color, distributor, and region.
CertainTeed currently offers Carriage House, which it describes as having a hand-crafted scalloped cut designed to mimic natural slate.
Before selecting a roof based on a specific decorative shingle, homeowners should verify current product availability with the manufacturer and roofing contractor.
What If My Existing Scalloped Shingles Are Discontinued?
Older decorative shingles can become difficult to match when a manufacturer discontinues a product, color, or design.
If only part of the roof is damaged, the contractor may need to determine:
Who manufactured the existing shingle
Whether the product is still available
Whether the color still exists
Whether a comparable replacement can be sourced
Whether the new product will physically and visually match the old roof
This can become especially important during storm damage and insurance roof repairs.
Internally link this section to your ITEL Report article.
Can Scalloped Shingles Be Repaired
If replacement shingles are still available and the surrounding roofing is in good condition, isolated damaged shingles may be repairable.
However, older decorative roofs can become difficult to repair when the original shingle has been discontinued or the existing roof has changed color from years of weather exposure.
If matching material cannot be found or damage is widespread, complete roof replacement may be worth considering.
Do New Scalloped Shingles Match Old Ones?
Even if the same or similar product is available, older roofing materials may have changed appearance because of:
Sun exposure
Rain
Snow
Algae
Granule loss
Age
Manufacturing changes
Years of Northeast Ohio weather
The replacement material should be physically and visually evaluated before completing a visible repair.
Are Scalloped Shingles More Expensive?
Scalloped or luxury asphalt shingles can cost more than standard architectural shingles because they may use heavier construction, more elaborate designs, specialized accessories, and premium manufacturing.
Installation cost can also depend on:
Roof pitch
Roof complexity
Turrets
Dormers
Valleys
Roof height
Material waste
Shingle product
Flashing
Roof decking
The best way to determine the actual price difference is to compare complete roof replacement estimates using the specific products being considered.
Scalloped Shingles vs Standard Architectural Shingles
Standard architectural shingles are one of the most common choices for Northeast Ohio roof replacement because they provide dimensional appearance, broad availability, and numerous colors.
Scalloped or luxury shingles provide a more distinctive architectural appearance.
Standard architectural shingles may make more sense when homeowners prioritize:
Cost
Availability
Simple replacement matching
Traditional appearance
Luxury scalloped-style shingles may make sense when homeowners prioritize:
Historic appearance
Slate-inspired design
Distinctive curb appeal
Premium roofing aesthetics
Scalloped Shingles vs Natural Slate
Scalloped asphalt shingles can create a slate-inspired appearance without being natural slate.
Natural slate is an entirely different roofing material with different weight, installation, structural, maintenance, and cost considerations.
Luxury asphalt products can provide some of the visual character of slate while remaining part of an asphalt roofing system.
CertainTeed specifically markets Carriage House as creating the appearance of scalloped-edge natural slate.
Can Scalloped Shingles Be Installed on a Steep Roof?
Yes, depending on the particular roofing product and manufacturer installation requirements.
Decorative shingle patterns can be especially visible on steep roofs because more of the roof surface can be seen from ground level.
The contractor should always follow the specific manufacturer’s requirements for slope, fastening, underlayment, starter shingles, ridge accessories, and installation.
Are Scalloped Shingles Good for Northeast Ohio Weather?
The performance of a scalloped-style roof depends on the actual roofing product rather than the decorative shape alone.
Northeast Ohio homes face:
Heavy rain
Lake-effect snow
Ice
High winds
Freeze-thaw cycles
Summer heat
Storm damage
Homeowners should evaluate the manufacturer’s wind rating, impact rating where relevant, warranty, installation requirements, and complete roofing system before choosing a decorative shingle.
Some current luxury products also offer enhanced impact and wind performance, but homeowners should compare the specific product rather than assuming all scalloped shingles perform the same way.
Are Scalloped Shingles Good for Historic Northeast Ohio Homes?
Northeast Ohio has many older homes where the architectural appearance of the roof is an important part of the property.
When replacing roofing on a Victorian, Tudor, cottage-style, or other historic-looking home, a designer shingle may provide a closer visual fit than a basic asphalt shingle.
Homeowners should also determine whether local historic-district requirements apply before significantly changing the appearance of an older property.
Do Scalloped Shingles Require Special Installation?
The specific installation requirements depend on the manufacturer and product.
Designer or luxury shingles may require particular:
Starter shingles
Fastening patterns
Exposure
Alignment
Hip and ridge accessories
Underlayment
Flashing details
Roof slope
Installation instructions
The contractor should follow the manufacturer’s published instructions rather than treating every decorative shingle like a standard three-tab product.
Should I Replace Scalloped Shingles With Architectural Shingles?
It depends on what you want from the new roof.
If the existing decorative roof is being completely replaced, homeowners may choose to:
Maintain the scalloped or historic appearance
Switch to a standard architectural shingle
Choose another premium designer shingle
Use a slate-inspired asphalt product
The decision can depend on budget, home architecture, product availability, warranty, color, weather performance, and personal preference.
A complete roof replacement gives homeowners more options than trying to match one small section of an older decorative roof.
Scalloped Shingle Roof Replacement in Northeast Ohio
S&K Construction And Remodeling LLC provides asphalt shingle roof replacement and premium roofing options throughout Northeast Ohio.
We help homeowners compare roofing materials, colors, architectural styles, warranties, roof replacement costs, and complete roofing systems before selecting a new roof.
If your existing decorative or scalloped shingles are old, damaged, discontinued, leaking, or difficult to match, we can inspect the roof and discuss replacement options that complement the architecture of your home.
We serve homeowners throughout Cleveland, Lake County, Ashtabula County, Geauga County, Trumbull County, Summit County, and surrounding Northeast Ohio communities.
Why Choose Scalloped Roof Shingles?
Scalloped roof shingles are an excellent option for homeowners looking to add a unique and charming touch to their roof. They combine the practical benefits of asphalt shingles with the decorative appeal of a classic, curved design. Whether you’re looking to enhance the curb appeal of a historical home or give your modern home a touch of elegance, scalloped shingles offer versatility, durability, and affordability.These materials contribute to a complete and durable roofing system.
Additionally, scalloped shingles provide excellent protection for your home, with their ability to withstand harsh weather conditions and offer long-lasting performance. With various color options and styles, scalloped shingles can be tailored to suit any design preference, helping you create a beautiful roof that complements the rest of your home’s exterior.For best results, work with a trusted roofing contractor to ensure proper installation.
Conclusion
Scalloped roof shingles are more than just a decorative element—they’re an investment in your home’s beauty, durability, and value. Whether you’re upgrading your existing roof or building a new home, choosing scalloped shingles can make a significant impact on the overall aesthetic of your property. From their timeless charm to their cost-effectiveness and easy maintenance, scalloped shingles offer a stylish and practical solution for homeowners who want to elevate their roof’s design.
At S&K Construction and Remodeling LLC, we specialize in high-quality roofing services, including the installation of scalloped roof shingles. If you’re considering adding this decorative feature to your home, our team of experienced professionals is here to help. We serve homeowners across Northeast Ohio, providing expert advice, seamless installations, and excellent customer service.
Contact us today to learn more about scalloped roof shingles and how they can enhance the look and performance of your roof replacement.
Call today to schedule your roof estimate
Scalloped and other designer asphalt shingles can give a home a distinctive slate-inspired or historic appearance while remaining part of a modern asphalt roofing system.
If your existing decorative shingles are aging, damaged, leaking, discontinued, or difficult to match, S&K Construction And Remodeling LLC can inspect your roof and help you compare replacement options.
We provide asphalt shingle roof replacement, roof repair, storm damage inspections, and roofing estimates throughout Northeast Ohio.
Schedule your free roof inspection and estimate today.
