(440) 307-2060
What Does Two Layers Of Shingles Look Like? A Homeowner’s Visual and Practical Guide
If you’re planning to replace your roof or inspecting an older one, you might come across a common scenario: discovering that there are already two layers of shingles on the roof. That raises a key question many homeowners ask—what does two layers of shingles look like and how can you tell if your roof has them?
Visually, a roof with two layers might not look drastically different from a single-layer roof at first glance, especially if the top layer was recently installed. However, once you know what to look for, the signs become clearer. From a construction perspective, this layering practice can impact everything from weight load to ventilation and future replacement costs.
This post will walk you through how to identify two layers of shingles, why some roofs are double-layered, the pros and cons of this approach, and what it means for your home’s health, value, and safety.
1. Understanding the Basics: Why Roofs Sometimes Have Two Layers of Shingles
In roofing terms, “two layers of shingles” means a second layer of asphalt shingles has been installed directly over the first one without removing the original layer. This is called a roof overlay or re-roofing.
Homeowners or contractors sometimes choose this method as a cost-saving measure. Since tearing off the old shingles takes time, labor, and disposal fees, skipping that step can lower the upfront cost of a roof replacement.
Common Reasons for Double Layering:
- To save money on tear-off labor and landfill disposal
- Quick fixes for older roofs with minimal visible damage
- A temporary solution to extend the life of a failing roof
- Situations where building codes allow overlaying
However, not all roofs are suitable for this method, and the benefits may not outweigh the long-term issues that can arise.
2. What Does Two Layers of Shingles Look Like?
A. Visual Signs
While it can be hard to tell at a glance, there are subtle differences that may indicate two layers:
- Thicker profile: The roof looks slightly more elevated or “puffed” compared to standard single-layer installations.
- Edges and eaves: Look at the drip edge or rake edge. You might see a stacked appearance or uneven edge profile.
- Layered valleys: Where two roof planes meet (called valleys), you may notice overlapping or bulkier material.
- Wavy or uneven surface: Especially over time, the second layer may settle over the old shingles’ texture, creating visible bumps.
B. Physical Indicators
If you’re on a ladder or working with a contractor, closer inspection can reveal more obvious signs:
- Double nail heads: Two sets of nail holes may be visible from the attic or on a removed shingle.
- Exposed underlayment: In some cases, water damage may expose multiple layers.
- Increased weight: The roof may feel heavier underfoot or show stress in areas with framing issues.
3. Is It Legal or Allowed to Have Two Layers?
Building codes vary, but many municipalities allow a maximum of two layers of asphalt shingles. Adding a third layer is typically against code due to structural and safety concerns.
Why more than two layers aren’t permitted:
- Weight concerns: Asphalt shingles are heavy. Two layers can add up to 600+ pounds per roofing square (100 square feet). Most roofs aren’t engineered to support that much extra weight.
- Ventilation and heat issues: More material traps more heat, increasing attic temperatures and reducing shingle lifespan.
- Inspection difficulty: Damage on the bottom layer can go unnoticed, which makes assessments and repairs harder.
Always check your local building codes or consult with a licensed roofer before considering layering.
4. Pros and Cons of Having Two Layers of Shingles
Pros:
1. Lower upfront cost
The biggest advantage of a second shingle layer is the savings. Skipping tear-off reduces labor and disposal fees.
2. Faster installation
Because the contractor doesn’t have to remove the original shingles, the project moves more quickly.
3. Temporary solution
If a full replacement isn’t financially feasible right now, a second layer may serve as a short-term fix for leaks or cosmetic damage.
Cons:
1. Shorter lifespan
The second layer of shingles won’t last as long. The trapped heat and uneven surface below contribute to faster wear.
2. Traps moisture
If any damage exists under the first layer, the second layer seals it in, increasing the risk of rot and mold.
3. Voided warranties
Many roofing manufacturers void warranties on shingles installed over another layer.
4. Added weight
Two layers of asphalt can push your roof’s load-bearing limits, especially in areas with snow or rainfall.
5. Higher replacement cost later
Eventually, you’ll need to remove both layers. That means more labor, more disposal, and more money down the line.
5. How to Know If You Have Two Layers of Shingles
If you’re buying a home or can’t tell whether your existing roof has one or two layers, there are a few ways to find out:
A. Visual Inspection
Use binoculars from the ground to look for tell-tale signs like:
- Thicker edges at the eaves
- Lumpy or uneven texture on the surface
- Bulging around flashings and valleys
B. Attic Inspection
From inside your attic, look for nails coming through the decking. Two sets of nails or inconsistent penetration depths can indicate multiple layers.
C. Remove a Shingle Sample
This is something best left to professionals. A roofing contractor can lift a small area to check for additional layers beneath the top course of shingles.
D. Ask for Documentation
If you’re buying a home, request previous roofing invoices or inspection reports. This might reveal whether a tear-off or overlay was done.
✅ End of Part 1
In Part 2, we’ll cover:
- The installation process for a second shingle layer
- Cost comparison: overlay vs. full replacement
- How two layers affect insurance and resale value
- When to remove both layers
- FAQs about double-layer roofs
- 440-235-3124
