7 Tips When Hiring a Roofing Company for an Insurance Claim

by | Mar 28, 2025 | Blog

7 Tips When Hiring a Roofing Company for an Insurance Claim

When your roof is damaged, the process of getting repairs or replacement covered through insurance can be overwhelming. The complexity of insurance claims, the pressure to get it done quickly, and the need to choose the right roofing contractor to handle your roofing issues can make the situation even more stressful. To help guide you through this process, we’ve put together seven essential tips to consider when hiring a roofing company for an insurance claim.

Choosing the right roofing company is crucial not only for the quality of the work but also to ensure your insurance claim is handled properly. The right contractor will help you navigate through the insurance process, restore your roof to its original condition, and protect your home for years to come. In this blog post, we will explore each tip in detail to ensure you make an informed decision when hiring a roofing company to handle your insurance claim.

1. You Get to Choose the Roofing Company

One of the most important things to understand about roof repairs or replacements after an insurance claim is that you, as the homeowner, have the right to choose the roofing company you want to work with. Insurance companies may have preferred contractors, but you are not obligated to hire those contractors. While it’s convenient to let the insurance company handle the selection process, you should not feel pressured to use a roofing company that you aren’t comfortable with.

Insurance companies may have agreements with certain contractors to help expedite claims, but it’s important to remember that this decision should always be in your hands. Take the time to research potential roofing companies, check their reputation, and review their experience with insurance claims. Don’t rush into a decision simply because your insurance adjuster suggests a particular company. By choosing a roofing company with the right experience and a strong track record, you’re ensuring that the repair or replacement process is done correctly, and that your insurance claim is handled efficiently.

2. Only Consider Roofing Companies with Insurance Experience

When selecting a roofing company to handle your insurance claim, make sure they have experience working with insurance companies. Handling insurance claims can be a complicated process, so you need a roofing company that understands the nuances of working with your insurance provider, including negotiating with adjusters, submitting claims, and ensuring the work is done according to your policy’s requirements.

A roofing company with insurance claim experience will be well-versed in the following:

  • Assessing damage: Experienced contractors will know how to thoroughly inspect your roof and document the damage in a way that aligns with your insurance policy’s requirements. This helps ensure that all eligible repairs are covered by your insurance provider.
  • Filing claims: A roofing company with experience working with insurance claims can assist you with the paperwork, helping you file your claim correctly and on time.
  • Negotiating with adjusters: Insurance claims often involve negotiations with the insurance adjuster to determine the value of the claim. A roofing company with insurance experience will know how to deal with adjusters to make sure you’re getting the right amount for repairs or replacement.

Choosing a roofing company that has experience handling insurance claims can save you a lot of hassle and ensure that the process runs smoothly. It can also help minimize delays in getting your claim processed and your roof repaired or replaced.

3. Only Consider Roofing Companies with a Local Address and Phone Number

When hiring a roofing company for an insurance claim, it’s important to choose a company with a local address and phone number. A company with a physical office and phone number in your area will be easier to contact if you have any issues or questions after the work is completed. It also ensures that the roofing company has a stable and reliable presence in your community.

Roofing companies that are based locally are generally more invested in their reputation and work quality because they rely on positive word-of-mouth and repeat business within their community. Additionally, if there’s an issue after the work is completed, a local roofing company is much more likely to be responsive and able to address the problem quickly.

On the other hand, roofing companies that operate remotely or without a physical location may be harder to reach if there are any issues after the job is finished. In some cases, these companies may even disappear after completing the job, leaving you with no recourse if something goes wrong.

Before hiring a roofing company, verify their address and phone number. Ensure that their business is located in your area and that you can easily reach them in case of any future concerns or warranty issues.

4. There’s No Reason to Get Multiple Quotes

When it comes to roofing insurance claims, many homeowners believe they need to get multiple quotes from different contractors to ensure they are getting the best price. However, this may not be necessary or beneficial in the context of an insurance claim.

Here’s why there’s no need to get multiple quotes:

  • Insurance coverage: The amount of coverage for your roof repair or replacement is determined by your insurance provider, not by the roofing company’s quote. Once your insurance company provides the coverage, you’ll know the amount they are willing to pay, and you can choose a roofing company that is within that budget. Most reputable roofing contractors will work within the limits of your insurance coverage, so there’s no need to shop around for the best price.
  • Quality matters more than price: The quality of the materials and craftsmanship should be your primary concern when choosing a roofing company, not the lowest price. A company that offers a significantly lower price than others may be cutting corners, using inferior materials, or providing subpar craftsmanship, which can lead to future problems with your roof.
  • Streamlined process: Getting multiple quotes can complicate the process and delay the work. It’s easier and faster to choose a reputable roofing company with insurance claim experience and work within your insurance coverage, rather than wasting time comparing quotes.

Instead of focusing on getting multiple quotes, focus on finding a trustworthy roofing company with experience working with insurance claims. This will help you make a more informed decision and streamline the process.

5. Don’t Look for the Cheapest Roofing Company

When it comes to roofing repairs and insurance claims, cheaper is not always better. Many homeowners may be tempted to choose the cheapest roofing company, especially when they’re dealing with the stress of an insurance claim. However, opting for the lowest price can lead to poor-quality workmanship, shoddy materials, or even fraud.

Here’s why you shouldn’t look for the cheapest roofing company:

  • Substandard Materials: A roofing company that offers very low prices may be using cheap, substandard materials that won’t stand the test of time. While the initial savings may seem attractive, you could end up paying more in repairs or early roof replacement in the future.
  • Poor Craftsmanship: A cheaper roofing company may not have the experience or skill to properly install or repair your roof. This could lead to mistakes, leaks, or other issues that will cost you more to fix down the road.
  • Lack of Insurance: Some low-cost roofing companies may not carry the necessary insurance or licenses required for the job, which can put you at risk if something goes wrong during the project. This could also lead to issues with your insurance claim.

Instead of choosing the cheapest option, prioritize value over price. Look for a roofing company that offers a fair price for high-quality work, uses reliable materials, and has experience working with insurance claims. This will ensure that your roof is properly repaired or replaced, and that you get the best long-term results.

6. A Roofing Company Cannot Pay Your Deductible

It’s important to note that a roofing company cannot pay your deductible or cover any portion of your out-of-pocket expenses. If a roofing contractor offers to cover or “waive” your deductible, this is a red flag. It may indicate that the company is engaging in unethical practices that could result in serious consequences for both you and the contractor.

Why is this an issue?

  • Insurance Fraud: Offering to pay or waive your deductible is considered fraud by most insurance companies. This could result in your claim being denied or even voided, and you could be held liable for the damages.
  • Quality and Legality: A reputable roofing company should never promise to cover your deductible. This is a sign that they may be cutting corners elsewhere in their service, such as using low-quality materials or performing subpar work.

Be wary of any company that offers to pay your deductible, and instead choose a roofing contractor that is transparent about the costs involved in the project. Remember, paying your deductible is part of the insurance process, and trying to bypass it could lead to bigger problems down the road.

7. Don’t Sign Anything Before the Roofing Company Gets on Your Roof

Before signing any contracts with a roofing company, make sure that they have inspected your roof in person. Never sign anything before the roofing company gets on your roof and assesses the damage firsthand. An honest roofing company should always evaluate the damage before providing an estimate or contract.

Why is this important?

  • Accurate Assessment: A roofing company can’t provide an accurate estimate or determine the full extent of the damage without seeing your roof up close. Signing a contract before the company has inspected the roof could lead to surprises or misunderstandings about the scope of the work and the costs involved.
  • Avoiding Scams: Some roofing companies may try to pressure you into signing a contract without inspecting your roof, especially if they are looking to lock you into an agreement before you’ve had time to consider your options. This could lead to rushed, poorly planned repairs and could even involve hidden fees or costs.

Always ensure that the roofing company has performed a thorough inspection of your roof before agreeing to any work or signing a contract. This will ensure that the work is done correctly and that there are no surprises down the line.

Conclusion

Choosing the right roofing company to handle your insurance claim is critical to ensuring a smooth, hassle-free process. By following these seven tips—choosing a company with insurance experience, selecting a local company, avoiding the cheapest option, ensuring your deductible isn’t paid for, and never signing anything before an inspection—you’ll be well on your way to making the best choice for your home.

A reliable roofing company will not only provide high-quality work but will also help guide you through the insurance claims process, making sure that everything is done correctly. With the right roofing contractor, your roof will be restored to its former condition, and you’ll have peace of mind knowing your insurance claim was handled properly.

Our Recent Blog & Articles